While we loved seeing the great photos of Natalie and Scarlett in the March issue of W, the opening line of the article seemed a little far-fetched. It says, "It's not easy to find a man whose celebrity crush list includes both Natalie Portman and Scarlett Johansson." We certainly don't think that's true and lots of men would love a moment with either girl, but it got us thinking that everyone has to prefer one of these very different and both beautiful girls. So tell us, are you a Natalie or a Scarlett person?
Prada
Paul Smith
Aminaka Wilmont
I'm a "both" person
1Definitely Natalie. Love her.
2i like both..but i love natalie persona a lil more
3Gotta love Natalie. I would never choose the other one.
4Natalie for sure
5I have to choose Natalie. I'm definitely not a ScarJo fan.
6Goin' with Natalie.
7Definitely both. It looked like they had so much fun together in Berlin. If not, they're at least great actresses!
8Natalie, but I hated the dress that she's wearing in that picture!
9between the two dresses i choose Natalie's one because i liked the colour of the(blue&gray&blue) my favourite colours and of course a classic beautiful dress.
10I'm defnitely a "both" person. We don't get to see enough of stars who have their heads on right!
11hands down natalie!
12The invisible fourth option, neither. I'm not really interested in either girls.
13i like natalie, I fee like she's a better actress and I think she's just so beautiful. I doubt Scarlett could pull off a shaved head like she did!
14both! Although I don't think they compliment each other.
15They are both great!
16I like both
17wow im kind of surprised at the results, i thought for sure scarlett would be it.
18Love them both. Its refreshing to see two intelligent classy young stars not in rehab or getting busted for drugs and dui's.
19Natalie is my gal
20I love both of them but I have just a little more love for Scarlett
21I think Natalie is for nerdy guys and women because of Star Wars and her intellectual roles. Scarlet is rather mainstream because of her curves and just her looks in general
22Natalie
23I am not a big fan of Scarlett. In fact she gets on my nerves and have a hard time watching a movie with her in it. Natalie on the other hand is cute, bubbly and just seams nicer. Plus I took my kids to see Mr. Magorium's and I thought she was good in that.
24i love both but Nat looks sooo good here
25I adore Natalie (not sure why, but ScarJo sorta bothers me), as does my husband. Though, he likes both women and knows plenty of guys who are attracted to both. Weird.
26natalie. scaelett is sassy and ugly.
27Neither.
28Scarlett.
29They are both unique and awesome in their own way but I'm a NATALIE person. I think she's an amazing actress and very classy
30I LOVE Natalie, but can't stand Scarlett. I don't get the attraction to her AT ALL. I don't think she's all that pretty, never struck me as very smart, doesn't have an exceptional body, there's nothing unique about her look, and I wasn't impressed by her acting. I have never understood the thing with her.
Natalie, on the other hand, seems to have it all.
31Natalie. She is smart and cute. I think she is one the most talented young actress working today. I also dig her vegan shoe line.
32They both are talented actresses and I don't care who is more beautiful.
33I don't think either of them are talented actresses. I can't recall one movie that either of them were good in, maybe Lost in Translation because Scarlett barely spoke in that movie. Natalie's a bit prettier to me, but that's all.
34Can't I choose neither? They are both nothing special.
35Scarlett! I have a major girlcrush on her! And while Natalie is gorgeous, her "smart" comments make her sound not so smart sometimes...
36I never cared much for Scar-Jo until I read the W article online. She seemed quite fun and vivacious. Portman is more prim, proper, and poised, all admirable qualities of course, just not as much my cup of tea. In terms of physical appearance, I find them both beautiful, but Scarlet's more womanly so I guess she wins by an inch.
37natalie
38Um I'll take both please. Natalie is so beautiful in person. I sat across from her at a restaurant in NYC and could not keep my eyes off her. She just has a glow and looks like a nice girl. Scarlett I pretty much knew before she was famous. I worked for D & G in the showroom ages ago as an intern and remember helping her and mother pick out clothes for movie premieres. She was so sexy then but in a awkward way. She still had not grown into herself yet. Then vavoom she became a woman and now she's super coquettish.
39i really like them both...well, maybe 51% scarlett - 49% natalie!
40Do we really even need to poll this? Natalie of course! =) It's not like I don't like Scarlett, but I LOVE Natalie
41Natalie! Scarlett is absolutely beautiful too, but comes off as a little pretentious and is only impressive in her films where she isn't supposed to talk much.
42i love both, but love natalie a little bit more!
43Natalie for me, but if we were to poll the men, I think they'd say Scarlett.
44I prefer Keira to both of them. But Natalie looks so like Keira, anyway. Scarlett sticks in my craw a bit - she talks a bit like a man pleaser, I can't forgive her ridiculously archly archaic 'Besides, some fellows like the way I look' in Vogue a year ago. Oh really? Some 'fellows' like thin little girls with big knockers and blonde hair and big lips? Well, it's very brave of you to not give into body fascism and take your BMI lower than its current 19.5!
45Neither. I think they're both good actresses, and I'm really looking forward to The Other Boleyn Girl, but I hate their personalities.
46Love them both...but I tend to like Natalie a little bit more
47I will have to go with Natalie because she is so humble, beautiful and smart. She would be a great friend IMO
48
natalie 
49Natalie all the way!!! Scarlett is irritating...if she didn't have big knockers, she'd be just like all the other little blonde starlets trying to make their way in Hollywood. Natalie doesn't need to flaunt her body because she actually has talent and class. She can get by on those two qualities alone.
50Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.