American Idol was a rollercoaster last night. At first I was just disappointed that two of last week's strongest contestants kicked off the show with weak performances. Lucky for us it wasn't a complete waste of a night, since the final acts were very entertaining. Here's my two cents:

- Michael Johns was off the entire song.
- Jason Castro was just OK.
- Luke was the most improved from last week, but sadly after he performed, the show stalled big time. The acts in between Luke and Chikezie were basically forgettable.
- Side note: OMG fake rocker Robbie wears a wig. No wonder Simon has been hinting to the audience that he is a fake.
- Chikezie was the first fun performance, and he nailed the vocals. Besides, I just love saying his name. I'm not sure why Simon has such a hard time spitting it out since it's so much fun to say. I also loved the playful banter with Simon — always a crowd pleaser when done right . . . unlike David Cook.
- Cook's song was good, but the awkward exchange with Simon at the end killed it for me.
- Finally, David Archuleta is the cutest thing ever. I just want to go squeeze him. He clearly has the best voice of all the men last night, and he's only 17. Very impressive indeed!
For more AI goodness check out Buzz's fun recap and don't forget to vote on who is going to get booted this week.
Photo courtesy of Fox
















Adidas
Elemis
Maje
i watched american idol last night through all those horrid performances, i was really looking forward to watching david, and fell asleep boo, i was so mad when i woke up right after he finished
1I have a reeeeal problem with David Cook and I'm not sure why. It might be partially because of his hair.
2I hate that Robbie character, I hope he gets the boot soon.
Has anybody seen American Dreamz? He's JUST like the "rockin' man..genuine rockin' man!"
3I feel like maybe David Cooks main problem is that he's pretty much physically unattractive, and that's unfortunate. He looks like a dbag and I want to hate him, but he ends up sounding pretty alright so I'm conflicted.
4i def think this should only be covered on Buzz... these peeps aren't celebs.
5Muffaletta gonna win this thing!
6lol. i totally thought that was a wig.
7Don't you just want to shield little David Archuleta from all that's about to happen to him? He's so good, he needs to share his voice and joy, but yikes. Too sweet for the industry.
8I absolutely adore David Archuleta! His performance last night gave me chills! But I agree with you toby321 he seems way to innocent for this industry! But I can't help but hope he succeeds in every single which way possible!
I also really enjoyed David Hernandez performance. The boy has a real nice voice!
As for everyone else they really disappointed me!
9Hope the girls bring it tonight!
I like that David Cook said to Simon. What Simon said was completely irrelevant to the performance. And I like that David is a word nerd. And what David said was not "disrespectful", all he said was that he doesn't have to win Simon over, just the viewers. And he's right. I like Simon but he shouldn't have said anything about his video.
10David Archuleta I think is the only guy that could possibly win this thing! I can't wait to hear the girls!
11I love David Archuleta as well. He is such a little cutie.
I also really like David Hernandez. He was excellent last night too.
I want both of them to make it to the end.
12I was so disappointed in the boys last night! I had high hopes for Michael Johns and Jason Castro. But yawn, yawn. All the guys are going to have to step up their game to even try to hold a candle to fan favorite David Archuleta. He's ridiculously talented. But I love how the moment the song ends, he's totally a 17 year old kid with a goofy laugh. I agree with those above, let's hope he remains true to himself through all of the nonsense of fame. What a cutie. And let's hope the girls give better performances tonight!
13"Cook's song was good, but the awkward exchange with Simon at the end killed it for me."
I totally agree.
14My problem with David Archuleta is that he has a thick tongue and it really annoys me. My fave was Chikeze-it was just really fun and seemed to come natural to him. "Rocker Dude" is no longer a fave since he wears a wig, come on, poser.
15Agree on all accounts. Haha can't wait for the girls tonight!
After Archuleta performed, everyone else sounded like karaoke regulars. Haha
16And I love how Paula Abdul said [about David Archuleta] "I wanna squeeze your head off and... I just wanna hang you on my rear view mirror." HAHAHAHA
17so far the guys are so disappointing even Ryan keeps saying this season is the most talented in idol history but i just don't get it. can't wait to see the girls
18David Archuleta is the sweetest thing! He'll probably come out of this whole thing with a recording contract whether he wins or not... not to mention a huge fan following made up of crazy young teenage girls.
19Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.