Quantcast
 

Which American Idol Performance Was Your Favorite?

Thu, 05/22/2008 - 12:00pm by PopSugar
6,124 Views - 65 comments

Last night David Cook became our newest American Idol, and while you all were happy with the final result, there was a lot more going on last night than just the Davids duking it out. From the performances of former Idols to star power galore, there was a lot of excitement packed into those two hours. So tell us — which performance was your favorite of the night?

Source


View Photos: Carrie Underwood Seal
on Yahoo!

Related Pop Stories

Related Network Stories


 
 
 

65 Comments Add a Comment

  • blob's picture
    blob
    2

    was carrie underwood imitating Shania or what?

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • bythesea's picture
    bythesea
    4

    I actually liked all of them, but I have to say my LEAST favorite was David A and One Republic (it was a decent performance but not as good as the others, in my opinion)

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Briandiesel's picture
    Briandiesel
    5

    Carrie is just amazing in concert - her outfit was a little eh? to me but I love her

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • treb's picture
    treb
    6

    Bryan Adams was my favorite. It made me miss being in grade school and junior high and I think he looked great!

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Christina23559's picture
    Christina23559
    7

    Kind of torn, because I voted for the David Archuletta One Republic Duet, cuz it was awesome, but Carrie Underwood was FABULOUS!

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • yiddidea's picture
    yiddidea
    9

    Bryan Adams was awesome, as was Seal and George Michael. I loved David Cook's performance with ZZ Top though.

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • CMG's picture
    CMG
    11

    I thought Michael Johns and Carly Smithson were the highlight of the night. That arrangement of the Beatles tune was killer, and they sounded great together.

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • jackie b's picture
    jackie b
    12

    DC was my favorite but Bryan Adams was right there as well Smiling I guess I'm the only one who was unimpressed by Carrie. She did look gorgeous though!

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • divinedebris's picture
    divinedebris
    14

    I did not like the Seal and Syesha performance, to me it looked like she was trying to upstage him and just couldn't get there and her voice didn't fit with the song. Carrie sounded and looked pretty good, the shirt/sleeves was a bit much though-I agree

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • yiddidea's picture
    yiddidea
    16

    I agree CMG - Carly and Michael were awesome! How could I have forgotten them.

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • btweenthelines's picture
    btweenthelines
    18

    you forgot JASON CASTRO's fabulous "hallelujah"! we've heard it before, yes, but it was so much more passionate this time. he's really grown a lot over the past few months.

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • treb's picture
    treb
    19

    I agree the Seal and Sayesha song didn't work for her voice.
    My boyfriend even pointed that out last night and he could give two sh*ts about AI.

    I felt like that Carrie Underwood song was essentially the same song as her last big hit, whatever it was called. And I'm not entirely convinced she'd shack with some dude after a night of drinking.

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Renees3's picture
    Renees3
    21

    I'm with CMG, Carly and Michael were SO awesome! I want to hear them sing together more often!

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • LilaBo's picture
    LilaBo
    22

    i liked the opening song that david and david did together. but i liked ALL the performances last night! i'm tempted to watch it again!!!

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • cherrygirl143's picture
    cherrygirl143
    23

    I have to say this was one of AI's best finale. It was entertaining. The only performance that really sucked was anything Amanda did. Yuk!

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • whatever100's picture
    whatever100
    24

    You said it Cherrygirl--Amanda did NOT want to be there or something, because that was miserable. And I agree with everyone who commented that Syesha and Seal were bad together. Not a match made in heaven, and it really showed her voice's limitations.

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • celeb_obsessed25's picture
    celeb_obsessed25
    25

    TBH, I wasn't interested in any of them. They only one I fully watched was David A & One Republic. So my vote goes to that since it was a decent performance and kept me watching

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Cocoangel's picture
    Cocoangel
    26

    I'm with the others who were loving Michael Johns & Carly Smithson.

    I kept wondering if Amanda was high or drunk, something that made her disoriented. Girl looked like she was uncomfortable & forgot every move she rehearsed.

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Julie3110's picture
    Julie3110
    27

    Well I only saw the Jonas Brothers and I absolutely adore them!
    I'm sure One Republic was great too, that's a great band, and Carrie Underwood was probably good.
    I chose 'other' because I'd like for the Jonas Brothers to be in that list!! Smiling

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • sarahbeee's picture
    sarahbeee
    28

    Bryan Adams was awesome! And also, I loved Brooke White and Graham Nash. What a perfect song for her!

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • graylen's picture
    graylen
    29

    This was only the 2nd episode I watched, but I've got to say that I loved Carly Smithson and Michael Johns! I also thought that David Cook was 10 times better last night than Tuesday.

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • zombielove's picture
    zombielove
    30

    i looooooooove zz top AND i looooooooove David Cook, so my vote goes to that performance...sharp dressed man indeeeeeed!!!

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • gandalff57's picture
    gandalff57
    33

    I think the AI final show was very entertaining. I liked ZZ Top, Brian Adams and ESPECIALLY George Micheal. GM sang the most meaningful song of the whole evening (I guess I'm showing my age! LOL). I liked David A. better, but, do think the David C. deserved the win as AI. I'm sure all 12 of the others have had recording companies pounding on their doors, so, I am happy to see that they have achieved the success that they deserve. Hopefully, next years AI will be even better.

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • cubachi's picture
    cubachi
    34

    My favorite performance was Carly Smithson and Michael Johns duet of "The Letter." They have great chemistry. But I have to give it up to David Cook, he rocked that song with ZZ Top.

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • linds1019's picture
    linds1019
    38

    My favorite was Cook w/ZZ Top. Brooke and Graham Nash did a great job, as did Bryan Adams.

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • ilanac13's picture
    ilanac13
    39

    i liked carrie underwood's performance, but i'm surprised that jordan sparks wasn't an option there. hmm....interesting right?

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • sienna's picture
    sienna
    40

    I chose DC with ZZ Top - he kicked ASS! Totally in his element - it was probably a dream come true! It was funny for me to see some of the other people come back - I realized that Michael Johns wasn't that great! Not bad, but just so-so. Carly looked & sounded great. And Jason Castro - man, he is just BAD. I can't believe he lasted as long as he did. Just MHO.

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • Mykie7's picture
    Mykie7
    41

    Can I cast a vote for worst season ever? I tried to watch this season, I really did, but the contestants were booooooooorrrrrrrrrriiiiiiiiiiiinnnnnnnnnnnggggggggggggggggg. The only one even SLIGHTLY interesting was Brook White. Any interest I had went away when she left.

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment
  • sugarrr's picture
    sugarrr
    42

    oh wow carrie underwood looked like a white trash hooker....

    what a suprise! jk

    seriously homegirl has 0 class

    12 weeks 5 days ago Report Comment