Jessica Simpson and her shiny shiny bag grabbed some lunch in LA on Friday. It's been an exciting week in Simpson land with Ashlee confirming her pregnancy and Jess releasing her first country single, and it got us thinking about the sisters. Over the years, both Jess and Ash have had their ups and downs, but tell us — which Simpson sister do you like more?

















Chloホ
Bi La Li
Pepe Jeans
Plus, Jessica has better fashion!
1i prefer ashlee's music and style but now she's changed and got all that surgery to look like every other bimbo in hollywood, whereas jessica can sing better and has stayed true to herself
2neither
3why there are two pics of Jess? Isn't it a comparison between her and her sister?
4ive always liked ashlee better- even back when they had the ashlee simpson show. she seemed alot more like someone who i'd be friends with. jessica seems like someone who i'd talk crap about with my friends bc she just tries so hard.
i don't like that ashlee needed to get all the surgery she did but hey if she thinks it helped her self esteem then good for her
5i prefer ashlee's style and music. i'm not that into either of them though.
6I can't stand either of them.
7I don't really care but if I had to pick one...Ashlee. I like her music better and her style better. Something about Jessica irks me to no end! Annoying to say the least.
8I used to like Jessica better, but the way she handled her marriage/divorce with Nick really turned me off. I've always thought Ashlee was too "quirky" on purpose, and they both try waaaayyyy too hard! At least Jessica can sing without making that tasmanian devil noise and giving herself polyps. But then again she does make donkey faces. I give up. Not a fan of either any more!
9look at any paparazzi (sp?) photo of Jessica and you'll se that she's ALWAYS faking it, trying to be cute with her mouth open or posing in a way that no way near sexy! Seriously she's getting older yet still tries to look like a little girl - give a rest Jessica!
10neither
11i like both equally to be honest
12Neither!!
13I used to prefer Ashlee, but she just seems as if she loves the attention too much! I can´t decide, I don´t really care...
14neither!
15Neither?
16I like Ashlee so much better! Jessica has the better singing voice, but other than that she's just a dumb bimbo waste of space.
17Jessica. And Ashlee being real? I am not American but I read every where that she is fake? I don't know.
18I can't stand either one of them.
19I don't know it is but I love Jessica. I think she is so pretty and has great style (on most days).
20i agree with natalie besides there's no (both of them )button to select coz i love them both , sugar u gotta pay more attention these days .
21jessica....and nick sure isn't doing any better with that ugly thing he's with now
22BOTH! I have always loved them.
23Jessica of course love her outfit in the picture above
24I love those afflecks!
25I watched the Newlywed show and I was always on Jessicas side, 'till I started feeling sorry for Nick. I had never known anyone who didn't know how to do wash. Anyways, I still think Jessica is a sweeteheart, but she is not really a ho (pardon the term) because if she was, she wouldn't look so sorry when she is acting like one. You can tell it's not even in her nature and she is acting to get paid. When $ is the #1 thing, you do what you need to do to get it. That being said, how sad. I like Jessica and think the ice cream cone and car wash debaucles were unfortunate. Even I am tempted to tease her about those things and I think she's sweet!
26Neither. =/
27i don't care for either
28neither
29Ashlee! no doubt
30Jessica hasn't stayed true to herself, she's gotten quite a bit of plastic surgery as well!!
I think Ashlee had legitimate reason to want to have a nose job. So what that she did.
I picked Ashlee. but I'd rather pick an Affleck bro
31Ashlee!!! I can't stand to here about Jessica...
32casey affleck. hah.
33Jessica was hot a few years ago, now its Ashlee's turn! Jess has gone downhill for me
34Sometimes I swear this website sounds EXACTLY like my 7th grade gym locker room. How old are you guys? 13? I love the celeb pictures and stuff but these polls are silly and b*tchy.
35I dont like any one of them, but Jess is better
36Affleck brothers are hotter and more talented.
37Um, neither? I hate both of them in uniquely different ways for many different annoying qualities.
38Neither of them.
39I would have to say Jessica because let's face it, she's a sweet girl who shows that she has talent in singing. However, she isn't afraid to branch out beyond singing.
40I used to like Jessica and felt a bit sorry for her. Now I find her terribly uninteresting. Ashlee tires too hard. A fake punk is pathetic. I am not even sure if she can sing. Their Dad is just too creepy for words.
41Neither. Jessica perhaps slightly better. But three steps up from trailer trash in a way (apologizes to trailer dwellers; just an unfortunate expression).
42I can't stand either one. Jess is annoying and clingy and changes herself for every guy she dates. Ashlee is a fake punk rock chick with a plastic surgery problem. Ugh, can't stand either one.
43Give me the Affleck brothers any day over these two.
44Ben Affleck!! Violet's daddy RoCkS!!
45How is Ashlee getting a nose job qualify as a 'plastic surgery problem'? She got it to feel better about herself and what is wrong about that? Millions of women every year have plastic surgery.
46i like ashlee's music but love jessica, so sweet and funny!
47Woops, was I the only one that thought we were going to vote on the other Simpson's sisters, i.e. Lisa and Maggie????
48Jessica, but I don't care for both.
49I don't really like either of them anymore, but I think Jessica is more beautiful and has more natural talent. I also use to admire Jessica's morality, and I liked her with Nick until she randomly decided to get a divorce. I still don't understand what happened there...
50Anyway, I think Ashlee's songs are better, though, in my opinion than Jessica's because they are catchier and more fun.
Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.