Madonna

always the original

christina, def

yes Christina

trabnny clown

i saw the ad, and i doubt that it'll make me want to vote any more -but i thought that it was 'lovely'

love them both. christina's makes me tear up a little and madonna's makes me nostalgic for the simple 90's (when i was 7 with at least 5 madonna posters in my room)

Yay for Christina and her baby, much more natural. Madonna's somewhat annoying^^

The Madonna one doesn't seem to be taking it seriously...which is counterproductive, no?

Where's my neither choice?!

I'm a huge Madonna fan but this one definitely goes to Christina. I will have to say if Madonna created a new one, I'm sure it would be MUCH different from her old one. Or at least I would hope

Wow. I have to say Christina hit it out of the ballpark with this one. I'm sure she wasn't the one that came up with the concept, but the ad got me so teary-eyed. Beautiful and understated but such a powerful message. Kudos to her.

neither. one was boring and one was just plain awful

Definitely Christina's... But it would've been even more powerful if she wouldn't say anything after she stops singing. That kind of breaks the effect.

How does Xtina have more votes than Madonna?!

Christina but I can barely understand any of the words she sings.

i picked Christina cause her voice is so sweet and beautiful and made me so close to tears..

madonna is beyond obnoxious in that video. her face sure has changed

Christina hands down.

Im just wishing Madonna and all talks of Madonna would go away. She's trash.

Wow - Christina gave me chills and even tear up a bit. So beautiful

Christina! I love how everyone was all upset that she has that sweet baby wrapped in the flag but no one cares that Madonna has her skanky body wrapped in one.

it is sad how madonna's is so hipocritical.

it is sad how madonna's is so hipocritical.

it is sad how madonna's is so hipocritical.

That Madonna ad certainly is vintage. That's when she still knew she was an American. Wonder if she does Rock The Vote ads in England now with her British accent.

I liked them both, christina sings soo beautifully and madonna's was really cool and orginial.

Madonna's was tasteless. Christina's voice is amazing, but I don't think that ad will make anyone want to vote apart from her fans.

Who cares option?

neither of them would make go and vote, what would make me go and vote, is what this world turning into.

but i still chose CHRISTINA, because that was just BEAUTIFUL.

I really like them both for different reasons. Right now the Christina Aguilera one goes perfect. A young mother comforting her baby singing a song about America. The state of our nation. It just seems so right now and current. However the Madonna Video was perfect for the 90's. It was the height of the gay activism and one of the first few times we saw openly gay males on TV. The 90's was all about sexuality, activism, sex, and awareness. Both caught my attention as a kid and as an adult. " Power to people is as good as Sex".

yeah maddona did that and then joked later she didnt even register. great. i am a huge maddona fan but still.

we'll see if christina actually votes.

christina wins htis one.

both are horrible, (what's with the child in the flag? gee) i'd like to know how many people actually go to the polls because of seeing this
but props to madonna for keeping it funny at least

Christina's is definetly better because it is soo sweet and innocent but its really powerful! I just loved it, it made me tear up a bit because it was sooo sweet!

I found Madonna's ad disrespectful to the leaders of our country and it looked like she didn't even care!

Christina's is beautiful and sweet, and it moved me. Maybe it will move young mothers who realize that they need to vote to make this country and this world the best place possible for their little ones to grow up in.

I love both. Both videos reflect their different personalities and talent. And it was done well.

Christina: Her voice is a gift from God. I was deeply moved by her voice, too. She sang a capella, no less. Her voice was so beautiful, she did not need music. Wow.

Madonna: Sassy, sassy, sassy. And with her gays dancing in the background. Classic Madonna. I love it.

Weel, both wore @$$less & crotchless chaps at one point sooooo........ lmao, I am a silly girl

*well

I don't like either. Sure, Christina sounds lovely, but I'm really bothered by how she says "It's time to make history, it's time to Rock the Vote." To me, she's saying "It's time to vote for Obama," when the message is supposed to be "we don't care who you vote for, just vote."

Aww I love Christina's ad. It was so sweet and simple, but it was very powerful.

Christina's = beautiful & classy
Madonna's = trashy

Simpler times! The world was very different when Madonna did hers, and it was quite brave and cool having obviously gay dancers in it with her. Christina's is sweet and touching, with her little baby, and very 00s. But Madonna takes it, I think.

Christina! So moving, so beautiful. Madonna almost seemed like she was making a mockery of it. I love Madonna, but it didn't seem to me like it was taken seriously, and the right to vote is something that should always be taken seriously.

christina's was so beautiful, like she is realizing these thing will affect her child but madonnas was so stupid she was laughing in the middle singing

christina!

Christina

No offense but i'm not a big Madonna fan anyway.. so definitely Christina!

Madonna = hip, fun, cool

Xtina = zzzzz

Christina's has heart and full of symbolism. Like I said with another post on this site, this represents the future of America. Madonna's is just annoying... but it was a different time, where America was annoying haha!

I don't like either. Sure, Christina sounds lovely, but I'm really bothered by how she says "It's time to make history, it's time to Rock the Vote." To me, she's saying "It's time to vote for Obama," when the message is supposed to be "we don't care who you vote for, just vote."

To comment on Austindragonfly's response.... Every time there is an election we make history. This ad did not endorse any candidate. But for the record I'm for Obama!!! But reguardless History is made from the moment we wrote the Constitution that gave us the right to vote... to NOW! What we do now affects the future. We are making the history for our children.

I have to go with Madonna's