Katherine Heigl went from a chain smoking lunch with her mom right into an afternoon of exercise in LA yesterday. As usual, Katherine showed off an odd dichotomy between totally healthy and totally not, but no matter how she treats her body in real life, Izzie Stevens' health is in question. After all the Emmy-related controversy, the newest rumor is that the writers are looking to kill off Izzie in order to get Heigl off the show. Most of you wouldn't care if she left the show, but do you think killing off Izzie seems a little harsh?

















T-Bags
Ra-Re
American Vintage
nowadays, it's hard to find a celeb who doesn't smoke. gross.
1I used to like her and always defend her, but I am really starting to dislike Katherine.
2Yes, too harsh! I know I'm in the total minority who likes both Katherine AND her character on Grey's, so nobody cares what I have to say, but it would pain me if she were to leave.
3I liked her on Roswell a zillion years ago, but I really couldn't care less if she's on Grey's or not...the show will still be great without her and killing her off...GREAT STORYLINE!!
4That picture on the right is so deliciously awkward!
And she just seems really arrogant and disrespectful considering she hasn't done anything particularly great in her career, ever.
5The show will suffer if he character is killed off. It has already begun to suck anyhow, and the writer's strike hurt it with the hiatus. I don't care if she smokes, but her Emmy comments were unnecessary. I'll prolly still watch Grey's if they do kill her off, but it'll be like ER after Julianna Margulies left.
6I would care if she got killed off--she is one of the reasons I watch the show. And who cares if she wanted her name off the list--we should respect her more that she did that not make fun of her or dislike her.
7I actually think the show will be better off if her character were killed off. She doesn't bring anything to the show (not like she did in the first 2 seasons), now she's just this whiney blond blob and a kill off would make her gone permanently, which seems like an EXCELLENT idea from my view.
8I think they should just give her the WORST story lines ever and make her suffer through her contract. You know she is saying all this to get out of her contract since she considers herself "A" list now.
9i can't stand her... neither her character... they are both horrible...
Hunterme is right the writers should make her suffer a little
10good riddance
11I think we should come up with some great plot lines for her to suffer. Personally, I think the more embarrassing for Izzy, the better... yes, I am just mean
12How about the writers giving her uncontrollable incontinence and projectile vomiting for a few episodes?
Oh, and tia, where's your avatar?!
13I think she is shooting herself in the foot...she is a mediocre actor and being difficult and whiny will not win her any parts. Once she is off Grey's she will be forgotten. I have to say I am in favor of killing her off...but I really like the bad storyline idea too.
14And could they please bring Burke back??
bye bye katherine. hope the movie career as the next julia roberts works out
15what about to making her into a coma??... she'll have to be there every single day while the others have "interesting" stories to tell
16Gelita- I LOVE it! How about she shoots herself in the foot and as a result has to go into a coma and has all her hair cut off for some reason (let's uglify her!).
17The only thing about giving her the worst storylines is that she will continue to be on the show...UGH.
PS: idawson, I totally love Secret Diary of a Call Girl!!!
And Jude C, I'm looking for a new one!!!
18I say let the b*tch die ! Sorry, thats rude, but I couldn't help myself. I just can't stand Izzie. Or Katherine. You know what, I can't decide who I dislike least !
19thanks hunterme... and then maybe a window in her room is broken "by accident" so she gets some extreme cuts in her face... so she'll have to put up with hours in the make up room... just for been in a coma
20Truthfully, I used to give Katherine Heigl credit for making me dislike Izzie so much. It takes a capable actor to make you dislike a character, but realize they are actually such a nice person...HOWEVER...I found out that NO Katherine Heigl is just as whiny and insufferable as her character...UGH!!!!
21Too harsh? It's a fictional character!!! I really dislike Heigl for some reason, can't put my finger on what it is about her.
22Oh Brilliant Gelita. I don't like that she was ungrateful to the writers...and she bad mouthed knocke up saying it was sexist. This is the movie that made her famous! This is the movie about a woman who didn't want to marry a man JUST because she was pregant, a woman who had a good career and continued it and ended up with him because she found out she loved him. Then after voicing her opions about 'sexism" she went to maek 27 dresses...about a woman stupidly in love and obssesed with a man who doesn't love her..stabs her own sister in the back and all she can think and care about is wedddings and life is perfect once you get married...how antifeminist and sterotypical of women is that?! Boo don't like her...
23Gelita- I think this is the beginning of a beautiful relationship
How about a
horrible car accident in which she can never ever, ever, ever speak again and just has to stare out a window and act mute.
24they already give her horrible story lines, HELLO, when Izzie tries to save a deer??? WTF.
25If they get rid of this chick, i will start watching greys again
26like an autist?? and then she gets like pshyco because nobody wants to be with her... the only one is Dr.Torres and her girlfriend... so she kills herself maybe drinking some cleaning thing...
27i dont understand how she smokes and then has the endurance to work out
28They should kill her off, they should just give her some new disease where she poops her scrubs every episode. Grey's writers are you reading this?!
29that first should, needs to be shouldn't.
30Hahah, Lauren...her trying to save the deer was insane. With the reference to Bambi. I used to love Izzie, but her story lines were awful last season. I mean, if I were her I wouldn't have said what she did, but I can't really blame her that much either. At this point, I wouldn't be too sad to see her character go. And I agree with the poster that wants Burke back. Sure the actor seems like a jerk, but his character was so good!
31David Caruso.
32She reminds me of the characters (with the exception of George Clooney) who left ER and did not find the success they talked so much about.
33With the earlier comments, I now find it too hard to separate Izzy Stevens and Katherine Heigl. Her character off screen has affected her on screen character and I think it is that way for a lot of people.
34THIS IS NOT COOL.
35You know really to me, and this is my opinion, its not Izzies character that is so annoying as Greys. Frig that woman is just so "do i love him" "do i NOT love him" "is he, like, the ONE?" "should i tell him?"
You get the drift im sure
Now, I understand that killing off Grey would leave the show...well without its title character, and she IS a character I sorta love to hate, but seriously, outta the 2 Izzie's really not the most annoying one to me.
I can't see her lasting longer than 10 minutes on the treadmill because of all the smoking she does. But I like her and I do like Izzie...
I don't want her character to leave, but then again I'm getting kind of over Grey's anyway.
36Oh and Mod16, I am a smoker (gross, i know) and I frickin have trouble with the stairs, whats this girl on?
37I am so over Meredith too. However, luckily I can separate the on screen personality from the off screen. The person I liked the best was Addison, however I cannot wait Private Practice.
38Sarahlynn I totally agree with yoy but for me both characters are annoying as hell!!!
this is a great example of how other actors steal the main stories of the show... i titally love Dr.Baley and Mc Steamy stories...
39I'd love to see Izzie in a coma.
40And people in LA are so weird. They smoke, and also workout obsessively. Most of my co-workers are that way. It's more about weight than health, clearly.
okay, first of all, smoking? not good.
41second, Grey's used to be my favorite show but it has gone completely down hill.
I wouldn't mind it without her, she's not that big a part anymore.
dont go please!!I need Izzie in greys anatomy!!
42I don't watch the show so I couldn't care less if they kill her character. I don't like her because she keeps bashing every movie she does. Seriously if she doesn't like the material then why do the movie?? I also hated the way she blamed the writers of the show for her decision to drop out of the Emmys. She could have taken herself from the competition WITHOUT giving any explanations. If she has a problem with the writers she should discuss that with them personally.
43I love her no matter what she says so if they decide to kill her off I think it would only be good for her because the show is on a downward spiral anyway. She's really the only reason I've stayed watching this long.
44The writers should kill her off in the slowest, grossest most agonizing way possible. That way, those of us that don't like her can take joy in knowing that she's not being let out of her contract and she's miserable at work everyday.
45I don't think killing off Izzie would be harsh at all . . . I actually think that she deserves that because then she would be gone off of Grey's and the writer's wouldn't have to work with her again. The only thing that I wouldn't like about that is that I wanted Alex and Izzie to be together again (and they were making a lot of movement toward that lately). Other than that, I don't think I'd miss her on the show because she hasn't been contributing that much lately. And as for her excuse for her poor performance, a good actor could take any kind of script and make it good and worthwhile.
46good riddance.
47!!!!!!
Kill her off, then be sure not to bother with an Emmy campaign.
48She is worthless.
49Grey's is already going downhill, it use to be the best of the best but I've grown tired of some of the characters - on screen and off. Izzie and Katherine being at the top of my list. Despite how much I detest the character and the person, if she goes, it's one more core character that I don't think Grey's would recover from.
Doesn't smoking make it really difficult to work out? I've always wondered how something so damaging to your lungs can allow you to breathe properly when you exercise.
50Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.