is that winkies dad?

unconventional as in "I'm gay but wanted a baby so my female friend had one with me" or as in they call me "My Little Pony Parker" and no man would procreate with me so I had my gay friend impregnate me sort of unconventional?

Dan Jaxon, that hurt my feelings.

Lol, but it was funny though.

lol

Sounds like just about every other married couple I can think of or know!

ok

I hope it's not true!

Look at how they match -- totally settled-in married couple-itis.

And here comes the PR.

This is so sad

What is that ridiculous necklace he is wearing?

They look so awkward together.

whatever...they're not the first and won't be the last to fall out of love...I wouldn't want to be with a man who's not in love with me anymore b/c I need that emoitional connection; and sex...I understand staying together for the kids sake and all that but mommy and daddy have to enjoy life too...as long as there's respect between the parents, splitting up doesn't have to be the end of life as we know it...and why put on show for the public, not for nothing, who the f*** cares what we think

I see the tabloids have turned there "helping along the divorce rate" eye on to yet another Hollywood couple. At this moment I call BULLSHEETZ on the cheating, the unconventional marriage, and the "not in love anymore" stories. UGH...

She looks cute but he doesn't. I hope that they make it.

i don`t know why but they don`t look like newly-married...Hahaha

Did anyone see the supposed picture of him and his supposed lover in Star? The entire picture is pixelated so that you can't see either of them at all. And that's supposed to be convincing proof.

Re-reading her quote now regarding staying together forever after hearing about these allegations brings a new light to what she said.

She didn't even talk about her feelings for him; she simply talked about James' feelings for him. Avoidance?

Tabloids like to zoom into a married couple and make a divorce countdown. So annoying.

I agree Juicylemon. It's very annoying. Hopefully this couple will be strong enough to avoid what the tabloids are trying to do...as we've seen in the past, some couples fall victim to the tabloids and their rumors (Nick Lachey and Jessica Simpson).

Ferris Bueller is NOT gay!! This 80's girl will not have it!!!

I doubt Matthew has the stones to cheat... he seems like the faithful kind..

I think this could just be tabloid fodder.. grain of salt people.

For all you know still waters run deep and they keep the kids up at night with the bedroom time antics.. who knows?

i love her hair. but she doesn't look happy at all.

Arg.. and I hate these pictures cause you know the assholio paps are saying things like "when is the divorce" "any comment about the affair?""are you going to forgive him Sarah?"

paps need muzzles.. oh and morals or a conscience might be nice.. but then again..if they had that.. they wouldn't be a pap.

The necklace screams mid-life crisis!

Lol.

But seriously, I hope they'll be able to work things out.

i think that they've always had an interesting relationship, so it's nothing new to see that they aren't your typical married couple. i don't know if it's fair for us to presume what their relationship is like and if they are in or out of love. we should just let them be and figure things out for themselves. they've been together for ages - and that's something to be impressed about in hollywood

I hate that stupid line, "they aren't in love anymore." Love is a choice! You either CHOOSE to stay married or not. It's not going to feel like it did the first few years. People just don't get that nowadays! Everyone expects marriage to be so peachy, but the truth is sometimes it sucks and then you move on and gets better.

I love her and I hope that whatever is going on is the way she wants it to be.

What the F is his necklace? Anyone? What the F!

I hope the rumors about them aren't true, but that necklace on Matthew isn't helping the gay rumors...

i hope he didn't actually cheat on her and that they can work things out too

so sad, and she looks sad too. i hope it all works out and they get the privacy that they deserve . . .

I'm not leaving him because he cheated on me, I'm leaving him because of that necklace he's wearing.

He isn't wearing a wedding band.

Oh, I wish we would all leave them alone now, including me clicking on this link. Poor people.

If it's true, what a jerk.

personally, i would rather have the story out there that "my husband cheated on me" than "our marriage was a total sham because he's gay and he left me for a man". so i'm thinking in a few months they will file for divorce and each of them decline to comment further saying "we remain the best of friends and support each other", blah, blah, blah.

I hope that this isn't true and that if they are, indeed, having problems that they are able to work them out.

does anyone know what brand of jeans she is wearing???

cut/color are awesome!

OOOO she looks gooooooooooooood

She is looking so GOOD! I love her eyes... I still fine it hard to imagine her with anyone but Big... and yes I know she only plays Carrie on tv and movies! HAH but she needs to hold on to Matt, b/c its cheaper to keep em... and we all know she is making the money!

I don't think she looks happy at all...

You guys honestly expect them to look happy with paps in their face probably screaming out questions about this "affair"?

Remember that Star Mag was the only source to find or publish anything about the story. Please, don't be so stupid as to not use your common sense on this one.

HE IS SO GAY!! I HAVE ALWAYS SAID THIS AS SHE IS HIS BEARD!!!!!!!!!! THE SO CALLED "OTHER WOMAN" IS JUST A COVER UP AS HE IS INTO DUDES!!! AND JUST WILL NEVER ADMIT IT!!!!!!!!