I just love The Notebook too much to see her with anyone else!

I wanted to pick both! I think they would be cute together, but I still will never stop hoping!

They're cute but Rachel&Ryan ftw

yes i can see this, hes so sexy, spesh his accent, first ryan gosling now him, uh so envious!

Nope, I'm in denial, she obviously has gone for Ryan look-a-like, which means she's not over him yet...yep they'll be back together.

Like I said I'm in denial??

she's adorable...and i like her taste in men! ryan and now josh?! lucky gal!

If Rachel and Ryan still don't have it together, than its time to move on. Its on again its off again, they need to move on. Actually Josh kind of looks like Ryan.

i agree with others- i'm still holding out hope for her and ryan but that said, i do like josh- he's a cutie!

Yes. If they are happy together why not

I think that she has excellent taste in men!!

i think that i kind of like them together. i think that he's adorable and she's a sweetheart so this could be a cute couple

Sadly, I guess they're cute (enough) together. And I can always watch that video and remind myself what was.

Um, don't think it really matters what WE like. LOL

Rachel and Ryan forever! She will eventually go back to him *fingers crossed*

I am still holding out for Rachel and Ryan, but we'll see.

if there must be a "Rachel and", it must be a "Rachel and Ryan." "Rachel and Josh" = fail.

Aww, I love powerhouse onscreen couples, and Rachel + Ryan were definitely one! I hope they're at least still buddies? That's the hopeful romantic in me talking.

Ughh clearly the thing w/ Ryan Gosling isn't working ( and as a fellow canadian this makes me sad) but I must say it is nice to know that she is getting some new loving from an equally hot man yumm
haha

I am totally on Team Ryan and Rachel, but obviously it is what makes her happy Although I agree with nonmember, he looks like Ryan.

QueenB75, I couldn't have said it better myself!!

i agree with everyone above. i, too, am hoping that rachel and ryan will eventually get back together. but in the meantime, she and josh are a cute couple.

Another C actor loser riding the wings of Rachel's rising star. I never even heard of the guy before now. Heartbreak City here we come!

Josh looks way too old for her, it might be his beard. Still rooting for R&R.

People should let her move on and be happy. She deserves it.

Ryan has moved on like 100x over.

And all the McGoslings need to stop skewing the poll!

i think it's time for her to move on

If you take the numerological equivalents of Rachel and Ryan you get 51 , and we all know what a number of destiny that is. There are 51 and 3/7 degrees in the angle of the Egyptian pyramids, which is 1/7 the arc length of a circle. Kepler identified the angle of 51 and 3/7 degrees as a septile. Western astrologers regard the septile aspect between planets to be one of a fated quality, because the number seven (septile) is related to fate in astrology. So as you see it’s just a matter of time before R & R are back together again…its in the stars..

I will always love her with Ryan, but if the timing isn't right for them again then I'm happy she's moving on. However, Lucas looks a little like Ryan! Time will always tell!

He's Ryan Gosling V 2.0, so yep, I can do it. I can see Ryan as being sort of moody (duh) which can be trying on a relationship so maybe it was too much?

Well if she's going to move on from Ryan, it might as well be with Josh Lucas Who, let's be honest, doesn't look that different from Ryan and is a cutie!

Time to move on for Rachel. This one at least looks like he takes a shower now and then

I think people who want Ryan and Rachel to date because of that movie are not right in the head.

If Ryan and Rachel have something about each other they love they should be together is not...they shouldn't.

I like Josh Lucas and if they wanna date I think they make a cute couple.

and gimmie a break Ryan doesn't look anything like Josh Lucas

Nah...not as cute as she can get.

he looks like a photocopy of ryan! gosh!

he looks like a photocopy of ryan! gosh!

call me old fashioned but i will never get over rachel and ryan

Well, if it ain't happening with Ryan - which it didn't on the second time around - then why not? Maybe they'll be happy together.

Hey, let's see the question strictly - do you like the idea of Rachel and Josh together? It was not asking about is it the time for her "to move on" !

Yes , i like the idea of "Rachel and Josh together" . But - only for 2 or 3 minutes in a bar some day, maybe , or even spending the time on a ceremony, but no more.. Ad all in all, who's that Josh Lucas ?.. Open your eyes, who on earth could compare him with Ryan Gosling!?
Not no not.

P.S. but yes, they have problems (look that MTV "Best kiss" ceremony , the link follows above). He (Ryan) didn't even pulled out his chewing gum when kissing her. But, another "bad sign" was that he was sitting behind her when announcing the winner (why?!).... Ohh. All in all they love each other, and atm she's trying to flirt with others while Ryan doesn't know (he's young) what he's doing wrong while being with her. ....
Ryan, do not munch your gum when your Rach is around you ! And - pick up a suit , a shirt and so on. Otherwise we'll blabberring here with such a pity theme - "Maybe it's time we get overЭ.. " She's a woman , and she may want you being more solid ? ..

â… agree with you.

thanks you, rec2
And again, look - http://images.popsugar.com/uploads/mtv.wmv
Not to offend Ryan, buy :
He's sitting behind Rachel while on ceremony (what could be the reason to behave like this while on the public?!)
He offers her stand up&go first (when the winner's got announced). I don't think it looks way too polite ..

He's still unshaven.. "Darfur" singlet (Do you think Rachel likes this ???...)
And, when he brings her to the microphone, he's face tells : I'm holdin a sack..
And, obviously.. he likes chewing gum more than Rachel's kiss
Sad..I'll try to guess that the biggest part of the reason they're apart (hope at the moment only) is .. on the Ryan's side

i think they would make a good couple and he has made no secret of wanting to settle down.

Hi. I guess I'm on the opposite side of the spectrum here, but I've never heard of Rachel McAdams until now. I've also never seen The Notebook (but will soon), however I am a huge fan of Josh Lucas, especially because of Sweet Home Alabama. I'm in my low 40's so I find Josh Lucas very attractive. If he's looking for a wife (as he's mentioned in interviews he is looking!) in Rachel, I don't see that happening. Gathering from other posts, she might be either looking for some fun with Josh or trying to get this Ryan guy jealous. Josh may not be as popular, but then again, maybe that isn't such a bad thing after all. Hoping for the best here...but then again, he needs to ask himself that famous line he said in Sweet Home Alabama, "why does someone have to try all the wrong things, before they find the right one." Makes y'all kinda wonder which one Rachel REALLY is...(giggles!) Take it easy on him, Rachel, o.k.?

I think they make a nice couple, but I'm hoping that Rachel and Ryan will eventually get back together.

i like josh... but sorry i love so MUCH to see Rachel + Ryan
they look so adorablee

I will never stop hoping for a Rachel and Ryan reunion!