Voting for this match is closed.
5 Katie Holmes
30 Years Old4320 Comments965 Fans
Pop Factor8.5Likeability5.6Class6.3Looks6.7Style6.5Talent4.9
45%
5 Katie Holmes
12 Carrie Underwood
26 Years Old526 Comments1,128 Fans
Pop Factor4.6Likeability7.6Class7.6Looks8.0Style7.3Talent7.9
55%
12 Carrie Underwood
More on PopSugar
Fall Award Season
Top Brands
Labour Of Love
Fendi
Too Faced