With all the controversy surrounding Nicole Richie lately, we almost forgot that Joel Madden had another serious girlfriend before he went and knocked up Nicole. However, in this month's issue of Seventeen, Hilary Duff reminds us of the two year relationship she had with Joel - and she's making her feelings about him loud and clear. Here's more:
On the breakup with Joel:
“All of the going out he did after we broke up sort of shocked me. Like, that’s just so out of character for him, and when we were together, he hated stuff like that, so I felt like I just really didn’t know him as well as I thought I did.”On Joel dating Nicole Richie:
“With the amount of time that we had invested in each other, I felt disrespected that he moved on so quickly…But some people don’t want to deal with how they feel, so they cover it up. Rebound! I shouldn’t say that. You know what, though? Now I don’t care.”
We can't blame Hilary for being shocked and hurt by Joel, but based on recent events, it looks like she got out of that relationship just in time. Besides, between her awesome bikini body and potential new hot man, we'd say that Hilary is doing just fine for herself these days.
More Hilary in Seventeen, so just read more

















Antica Murrina Veneziana
Les Nereides
Matches Fashion
That's a pretty good attitude. If I were her, I probably wouldn't be as nice!
1She doesn't look half bad here, and she's better off without Madden.
2She always sounds like such a mean-spirited, spoiled brat.
3I don't think it is mean-spirited at all. I would probably feel the same if a guy I had been with a long time moved on so quickly after we broke up. She and Joel were very open with their relationship, so it doesn't surpise me at all that she would continue to be open after the break-up.
4I should revise my statement by saying that they were pretty coy when they first starting seeing each other. But when they finally came out and said "yep, we're a couple" they were very open.
5I love her! She's gorgeous and I'm glad Joel is no longer bringing her down
6I think she can do much better than him.
7I don't think it's mean-spirited either. The girl has some really good points...a two year relationship, like she said, you've got a lot invested in that person. Beyond Nicole being a "rebound" girl for Joel, he went and got her pregnant. It sounds to me like the Joel after they broke up (getting into fights, partying, even dating Nicole in the first place) was very different from the Joel that Hilary knew, and in this article she sounds thankful that she is no longer a part of that.
8She rocks, her opinion's on her old relationship sound right on point.
9she is so NOT over him. her comments tell us that she's shocked and hurt. poor her.
10She's probably still hurtin' a bit, but I have to say that her comments cracked me up.
I'd feel the same way if my bf of two years moved on so quickly. Can't help it.
11Well, Joel and Hillary were a little coy since she was only 16 and he was a grown man 25 years old.
She is handling it well, considering she is so young and was probably very hurt.
This intereview was also pre-pregnancy rumors. So idk she would have said rebound before then. But it's still rebound with a pregnancy now.
12Why is this kid worthy of celebration? Honestly.
13nobody cares anymore
14hes got a baby mama now lol
go find a man hilary
go out with shia lebouf not brody d-list jennier
haha im kidding
but i hope hilary finds someone
she seems really nice
& i love that blue top..or is it a dress.. anyway cute outfits
jenner**
15HATERS! I HEART DUFF
16I think she looks 100% better now that she is not with Joel Madden. Something about her just glows now. I wasn't that much of a fan of hers but I admire how she handled things and she has really won me over. She was way too good for him.
17She shouldn't have said anything at all, usually she's classier than that...but what she said sounds pretty legit and sounds like it's all true.
18I like her a little more each time I read/hear about her.
But she's bordering on "the lady doth protest too much."
19I am tired of hearing about damn children. They are so young. I am in my mid-20's for crying out loud and it seems like all these so-called hot celebs are former Disney kids barely out of their teens (Duff girl, and Shia boy, for ex.).
Even as a kid, I hated hearing about teen stars (exception: Leo DiCaprio during Titanic-mania). It just seems they're everywhere now and during this time in our nations' history when the sh*t has totally hit the fan, I think my celeb intake can only handle so much nonsense.
20blech I can't stand her. She's such a passive aggressive little brat. That good girl act is so over done by her.
21
she nailed it, rebound.
22i don't Hilary is being mean at all, she just pointed out the obvious.
23um... why is hilary still talking about her relationship with Joel. I mean its been over for a LONG time now... move on!
24She looks incredible in all of these shots, I love the green shirt and the blue dress. Good for her for saying it like it is. And she is certainly better of without him.
25She's probably talking about it because she was asked about it.
26She looks innocent here..I like her.
27Why shouldn't she talk about it? It's a part of her past , I never understand whypeople are like why is she talking about it blah blah, hey if we have to listen to someone prattle on about deaths in the family or abusive relationships then we might as well listen to one about a broken relationship.
28I may be remembering wrong, but didn't she hold out for a long time? Especially with the 16 thing. But it seemed like she was saying she was staying a virgin (like Jessica?)
If so, maybe that explains all the PDA with and quickly knocking up Nicole. Too long going without
29ha ha! i totally have to buy this issue now just for that quote! hilary is great! she's so much prettier than nicole!
30go hil! at least she's got personality
)
31Nicole is just a bag of bones! (now with a baby in it
I totally understand where Hilary is coming from. The same thing happened to me. I was with my ex for 2.5 years and after we broke up I wondered who the hell he was since he completed changed. He started going out to clubs, which he always hated with me, drinking alot, which he always hated, he was dating someone new within a couple months of us breaking up. It was really hard and really upsetting since I thought I was going to marry this man and he turned out completely opposite of who I thought he was.
Hilary is entitled to feel that way. You never really get over your first love. It's been over 3 years since we broke up, and I still feel a little twinge of heartache over him. Especially since his girlfriend is a fug version on myself!
But now I am happily getting married in 38 days to the love of my life!
Hilary will probably always feel that way, and so she should
32Great Attitude!!!
33Go Hilary!
34She said it straight out. Nicole was pretty much a rebound.
haha he wanted sex, he got it and now with a big responsibility.
You go girl!
35he's a tool anyway.
36oh yeah and maybe she didn't want to talk about it because it was too soon for her. she was really hurt.
37i guess now she's moved on and ready.
let her speak out.
whatever...what was he meant to do? not date or have a g/f until she said 'it's ok i wont feel disrespected now', get over yourself hilary, why should he stall his life so that you wont feel disrespected...cry me a river and shut up its been months now.
38
39I just simplt love her, shes amazing.
40I vastly prefer her to all the air headed bimbettes out there and the fact that she was a superstar during Katrina helps. Shove Paris and LL and Nicole off a bridge and give me Hilary any day.
41
42I feel bad for her. Even though she's young - it hurts to feel like your relationship with someone was meaningless. (...him moving on so fast) She probably felt a bit rejected, despite the fact that they were already broken up. (and) To have to have it all happen in the public eye - harsh.
43good for her!
44lol nyar!
45you know, i'm only 2 years older than she is and i remember when i had a boyfriend at that age who "oh so important" and it was hurtful when we broke up. he and i have actually moved on and are really good friends now, but that age is really tough to get through and i couldn't possibly imagine doing it in the media like that. i'm glad she is doing well and she looks amazing! so much better without joel. (he probably on likes skinny anneorixic biatches)
46
47
48I know exactly what she meant, try breaking up with your bf and seeing him the NEXT DAY with another girl holding hands and kissing. That hurts!
49d-ford - I really tried for months to understand why would he wanted to be with that chick (They been together ever since). I mean maybe it sounds b*tchy and all, but heck is she fugly!!!
50Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.