You all entered some awesome captions in yesterday afternoon's Caption It, Sugar contest, but now it's time to pick the winner. (And yes, it was very exciting to see Ricky from My So-Called Life there too.) The funniest commenter will get a great piece of Sugar Swag. So now it's your turn. Which caption should win?

















Roberto Cavalli
Preen
Converse
Ummm...they kinda all suck....sorry.
1I voted Booty calls - it was cute and it went with the movie their filming.
2aaand I thought all of them were good
3i like the second 1......the rest suck
4"Booty Call"...lol
5I think they're pretty bad too....
6People, they're just silly captions. Loosen up! And I voted for ARRRRRR in honor of my PS piratey pals.
7Yeah seriously they are captions---i'm just sooo happy to see wilson cruz--ooh the memories!
8Uhm..they all kinda blow..
9None for me sorry!
10None of the above. I can't think of one either though.
11zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
12None...I don't really find them funny or cute. Sorry.
13Maybe because my sense of humor is too sarcastic, vulgar and harsh.
zzzzzzzzzzzz so boring.
14I'm curious if all you "haters" could up with something better?
This wasn't exactly
the easiest picture to work with for captions.
#3 is relevant to the movie at least, so I hope it wins.
And yay, "Ricky"! The last time I saw him was in "The West Wing".
15I agree freegracefrom!!!!
16You guys gotta start lovin' the pun once again.
17I voted for the Arrrrr one because it made me laugh and was very pirate-y
18ok true dey're all a bit cheesy but atleast they thought of smtg- i was completely blank
19heh i voted fr the auditions one.
the first ones the clear winner
20Agreed with freegracefrom. I liked better the #3.
21I didn't post anything . However, I still think the chosen captions are a bit boring. Doesn't mean I want to try and come up with one.
222nd for me .
23None of them are really funny. This was a hard one to caption.
24How do you know when a pirate is "just not that into you"? He only makes BOOTY calls is my fave. I thought that we were supposed to tell a pirate joke to enter though?
25I like the first one...but they all kinda...eeerrr...
26lame.
27The last one.
28Ahhhhh,,,,did we miss the boat?
29Not funny.
30anyone notice that drew kinda looks like john galliano here?
31None of them is really.. amusing.
32I liked lolabella's
"i dressed up and went to Disney, and all i got was this gay pirate."
33i voted for the first one!
34All three choices Blew so here is mine:
"The Firestarter and the Flamer"
35None are that funny. I didn't vote.
36I'm not too keen on any of them, sorry.
37Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.