it pwnd twilight within seconds but i still love them both !!

mmm yes...but i like Twilight too

They're both in their own ways. New Moon was better overall, grander, thoughtful, seemed like a real movie and more organized. E/B scenes were definitely rushed though. It couldn't match the chemistry of the bedroom and prom scene of twilight. Eclipse better not be an action filled movie and skim the E/B scenes...once again.

Yes it was better than twilight but look at the budget difference! New moon was more like the book than twilight was. Twilight should of had more things from the book in it, for example the blood testing and Bella getting sick by the sight of blood. I liked that part in the book! I still love twilight though Catherine did the best she could with the budget she had, but yeah I think new moon was better and I think eclipse will be better than new moon and breaking dawn better than that.IMO

ok i love twilight but new moon is better than twilight.

i think it was better...but i love twilight too....=]...i hope eclipse is the best movie out of all four because its my favorite book....=]

When I saw Twilight it was before I had read the book so everything In Twilight seemed so amazing and i could hardly anticipate what was coming next, where as in New Moon I read the book so i knew everything that was going to happen and it didn't captivate my interest as much as twilight had. I still loved it tho! and originally I was team edward but after seeing new moon i might hav switched sides, taylor lautner is so hott!

I think New Moon was so much better than Twilight! And let's face it Taylor Lautner is amazingly beautiful. He made the movie and he was amazing in it! Go Taylor!

New Moon was way better than Twilight because it stuck towards the book than anything else. Taylor Lautner is probably the only actor who used most of his lines from the book. Go Taylor! What really got me going over New Moon is when Jacob took off his shirt for the first time in the movie. SEXY HANDSOME BEAUTIFUL GORGEOUS MUSCULAR ABS AND ARMS!!!!!!!!!!! Plus I love those intense scenes between Bella and Jacob because in every scene it looks like they're going to kiss eachother. But they don't maybe I'll be able kiss those amazing lips of Taylors some day. Over all it's the best movie of the year, I would think.

I think twilight was better than new moon as Catherine gave a very stylish and modern look to the film while new moon was very commercial also the reunion scene of edward and bella was too cold it lacked that emotional touch. I hope summit makes up and brings back edward and bellas romance and chemistry in Eclipse/BD shown so beautifully by catherine in twilight. She did a brilliant job with such a low budget and the most important thing all the vampires looked old especially edward he was not looking 17 college going at all why was he in suits all thru out. Well summit sould try considering catherine back for breakng dawn part 1 atleast the wedding and honeymoon is very important in BD which she will potray well.

I personally didn't like New Moon as much as Twilight.
First of all ... it's the music ... I mean Alexandre Desplat makes nice movie songs and I like the "New Moon (The Meadow)" song but Carter Burwell would have been better for New Moon, just my honest opinion.Plus Bella's B-day song where Jasper attacks her was really lame.
The plane trip back from Italy or the waiting in the Volturi hallway should have been introduced in the film ... it was just to abrupt.One minute they're in Italy and the next in Bella bedroom.WTF?
Also the romance in New Moon is really gone.I mean the dialog isn't like in Twilight.Both Bella and Edward sometimes seam like they're really detached from each other and also from everything else.
Personally ... I think Twilight was the best movie till now.
Catherine did a better job putting S.Meyers book on screen.

Actually, despite the fact that it was low-budget, Twilight was much better. It had better dialogue, and more feeling. Cathrine did a much better job. I preferred the Twilight set, if you looked closely, Bella's house was different, and so was her school, and parts of Edward's. The music in new moon wasn't very good, either. I didn't really seem to fit Twilight saga as much. Although I loved Jacob, and the fact that it stuck to the book more, the ending was pathetic, and I sincerely hope that they hire Cathrine back.

no i think twilight is better than new moon, the only part of new moon i like is when jacob takes off his shirt, and i hate the ending on new moon.. STUPID.