Hilary Duff is turning 20 next week and she just received a huge gift from her boyfriend, Mike Comrie - a hot G-class Mercedes SUV! The hockey player surprised her with the $100,000 car after he overheard her thinking about buying one for herself. Young Hollywood certainly has cash to spare but don't these expensive gifts seem like a bit much? Hilary laughed off questions about getting engaged but this present sure screams serious. What do you think - are Hilary and Mike getting serious and giving too much?

















Just Cavalli
French Sole
StyleBop
Whatever-- it's her business and that's an amazing gift!!
1True dat princess-eab
2they have the money and its sweet they spoil each other! "normal" people like us cant relate!
3its perfectly fine so what?? its her business i agree
4I think it is fine that they are moving slow! and and who cares if her boyfriend gave her a car I think it is really sweet!!!! Go Hilary you deserve i good guy!
5it's just a stupid car. it's not like he gave her a kidney or his selfless unconditional love. at least she'll have something to drive her lonely ass around in three months from now when he leaves her for someone attractive.
6Puleeeeze...its waaaay to extravagant for such a young girl, even with all her fame and money. They have been dating for what?? A minute now?....its just a bit much.
Oh well...these celebutards do what they like...and all we can do is just shake our heads and wonder.
7Not my money, not my business.
8It's his money - if he wants to buy his famous girlfriend an incredibly expensive car, that's his deal.
9i would rather be given a car than a baby!
10Mike's family is loaded. He's the heir to a large business here in Canada, so I think the family money + hockey money = not such a huge gift to him. Besides, it isn't a super personal gift because he didn't get the idea himself, he took it from her.
11It always amazes me when celebs buy each other ridiculously expensive gifts. I think it's a rather lame gift considering money wasn't an object for her and she was going to buy it herself anyway. Sounds like he isn't very original and couldn't think of anything else to buy her.
12First..its way to expensive. Second, SUV's are irresponsible! They are too big, use too much gas, and why the heck does anyone need something that big to just drive around? If you are going to be high profile get a hybrid or something that at least gets decent gas milage. You can have class and look good AND be a responsible consumer.
13don't really care
14I like Hilary and receiving this gift makes me think they might get serious. I'm just concerned because didn't he used to date Lohan for a sec. A guy's previous girlfriends/flings are important because it gives insight to his personality. I want the best for Hilary so I hope this guy is good.
15hilary is a lovely star and she deserves it but at the same time it is an expensive gift n she's only 20 but at last he brought the car n it's his money ,for me (n 4 everybody) if some1 gives u a car as a gift won't u take it ?!!!
16A $100,000 car to them is probably like a $100-500 gift for us normal people, depending on income. But even if it were actually "too" extravagant, who cares? My boyfriend would buy me the world if he could afford it. (I would be a sweet world leader, don't worry.)
17I think that if a guy that I had been dating for only a couple of months gave me an expensive car, that he would ahem... expect something from me in return. Yes they have cash to burn but it's way too extravagant and it seems like they're moving too fast.
18They both have cash to burn, so why can't they spend it on each other? A $100,000 car to them probably isn't much, and it's nice to see Hilary getting on with her life, and not suddenly finding out she's gonna be a mother or getting engaged.
19It is totally her business and I think she found a guy who wants to spoil her. She is a lucky lady as I have a guy like that myself!
20the OTHER option should read "I could care less." lol.
anyways i agree with novaren, it's too extravagant for her age and how short they have been dating, like a minute right? lol. i also agree who said it's very unoriginal of him to buy her a car. i mean i'm pretty sure she can afford a better one.
whatever happen to flowers and chocolate?
21noo!! they are rich.. 100000 is pocket change.. its just a stupid car not a ring.. not that serious
22I think the car itself is too extravagant, not that the price of the gift was an issue. None of us need to be paying that kind of money for something that is so unnecessary and also harmful to the environment.
23But it's his money and their business.
I think it's way better to give her a car than an engagement ring or baby, which is apparently what Joel does =)
They have money to burn so to them it isn't extravagant. To the real world, hell yes!
24I don't disagree that SUV's guzzle a lot of gas and that's bad for the environment but to the Prius lovers - they aren't the miracle car everyone makes them out to be.
25To them, it isn't extravagant. To me, it is unattainable. To them, it is like a $200 bracelet. So ridiculous.
26Whatever. Who is anyone here to judge the gift-giving of people you don't even know personally?
27if you take there income vs the average couple, the gift is prob in line with what we all do for eachother:-)
28As others have already said, it's just money, and it's not like these people don't already have enough of it. However, personally, I'd like something that takes a little more thought than a car...
29Wow - He's a keeper.
I wish the car had been more green, but his generosity is spot on!
30I doubt the giving will be all one way and seeing as they can afford it and it's likely mutual giving then why not?
31I'm just glad that the guy behind her in the pics with the too tight Members Only-type jacket (soooo 70's) and the CIGARETTE hanging out of his mouth isn't Mike the car giver!! (I had to look him up. He's cute! Much cuter than Joel whatshisface, tatoo boy.)
32With the money he has this is not that expensive of a gift!!! Though I really wish he had chosen a more responsible vehicle....
33i don't really care either way cuz i'm not a fan of either of em.
34its their money so whatever
and lol # 6 comment
35well, considering what the both of them make, it's probably pocket change and no big deal. but it seems really ridiculous to me, especially since they're such a new couple!
36Definitely not! If Joel can give his sperm to Nicole, then this guy can give a car to Hilary. It's only fair!
37What happened to Hilary being an environmentalist and a normal girl? Just when I was starting to like her.
38When I first saw the title, I thought the two were giving too much for charity and was going to say, No way! Figures.
39Wow, that's an expensive gift, Comrie isn't even a top level NHL player but I'm glad she's got someone who really seems to care.
40ergh i would love to receive that give... but yeah i think is too much even thought they have money...
41I wish I knew someone who could afford to give me a car. If that is how he wants to spend his money it's his business. If he was my bf, i sure would be happy!
42I said yes. How long are they dating? About 2 MONTHS?
43Maybe he's either a.) trying to coerce the self-proclaimed virgin into unexplored territory or b.) over-compensating for something else
??
$100k is like $5 to these rich brats anyway.
44Psh, I wouldn't be complaining.
45that's up to him. and she seems like a great sweet girl and that's how he wants to show his appreciation. so what? who are we to judge. i don't know anyone that would be hurt by recieving such a gift.
46idk its cute
47and??
48it might be too fast only
49because i dont want her to
get heartbroken again..
but she deserves it! great
idea boyfrined!!
Eh...I get a little wary when new, young couples give eachother too much too soon
50Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.