they seemed to genuinely care for each other.

This really bums me out. I really really liked these two together.

haha!srry,i don't like hilary at all..i'm glad they broke up.. what was their age difference?

I really like Hilary! i think she does need someone a little closer to her own age and has the same beliefs as she does!

who cares.. I must be in a bad mood today,, NOrmally, I like hilary but today I Could care less if her and her b.f broke up.. Lets move unto bigger and better things....

I say as long as she doesn't start hanging out with Paris she'll be fine.

i like both of them just not together...he's like 27 and she's 20 thats too big of an age gap at that point in their lives... i hope they find other people to make them happy they both seem like cool people...

"stay far from timid, only make moves when your hearts in it and live the phrase sky's the limit."

They always seemed to be pretty happy together from what I've seen and read. This is too bad, if it's true.

Oh, I didn't think they made a good couple at all. It just really creeped me out that he started dating her when she was 16 and he was in his mid-20's. I am sure they will find happiness with people they each have more in common with.

she looks pretty here. She had her teeth fixed, I saw it on another site.

nooooooooooo

they didn't look right together in the first place.

I think if they're both above the legal age it doesn't matter a whit how old each of them are, as long as they're happy.

ehh she turned into a bobblehead, i could care less
i know he thinks you're fine and stuff but does he know how to wind you up?

Yes, they are both of legal age NOW....but it just creeped me out that he started dating her when she was 16.

sad..Hilary is the only non skank in Hollywood..Joel will come back for her.

I think if they're both above the legal age it doesn't matter a whit how old each of them are, as long as they're happy.
---------------------------------------------

Actually, she wasn't legal when they began dating...

I thought they were sweet together. Oh well, another one bites the dust

Thank you, Kyla....that was my point. I think they probably fit better with other people anyways. I always thought they were odd together on top of the creepiness.

I actually liked them after she stopped getting so darn skinny. Saw her on the view and she seems very down to earth. Much better than some other nasty girls we have been talking about on here!

why do guys announce that they are single like this? i think it's annoying and immature. do they think interested women will rush the stage or something?

shes young, she'll bounce back.

i think it was the horse face not the age difference that drove them apart. girl was kinda cute til she got waaay to skinny. these two never seemed right anyway...

I agree with Kyla,age doesn't even matter these days......so that couldn't have been a issue.Look @ Brad and Angelina,he's 12 yrs older

For some odd reason I just do not like her, dunno why? Althought I do like the fact that she isn't s*utting it up like most of her peers.

ee he was too good for her anyways..

He's single!!!!
________________________________________

Made in Brasil!

So sad. They're both ugly and untalented. They belonged together.

I bet HE broke up with HER because she didn't put out...she was waiting for marriage like so many youngins say these days.

LOL sica

how old is he anyway
whatever they never made sense

Oh, I love Hilary. I hope she takes it well. There's alotta other guys out there for her.

i don't know what to believe of this couple
i heard different things
although i think she dumped him, cause he is to sweet to do something mean
well now it doesn't matter anyway they are over
and whoever said he was a bad singer was wrong, cause he rocks