Wow, this is not the Katharine McPhee we remember from American Idol. That innocent girl from Sherman Oaks has clearly gone all Hollywood on us. She's the spokesmodel for Sexy Hair, but the hair isn't where your eyes go when you see the cover of her new album. What do you think? Is her new look sexy or slutty?

















JC de CASTELBAJAC
Geox
Nine West
Chris Daughtry all the way! (Yes, I'm biased)
She looks great.
1I feel like she is trying REALLY HARD to be sexy. Seems a little desperate to me.
2I think she looks great...sure it has a touch of sluttiness to it, but sex sells!
3Sexy from the Fag-a-lahs here at the office
4Sexy all the way.
5_____________________________
Brad is so hot!
She has been trying too hard lately for the sex kitten look. I liked that on AI it seemed that growing up in LA hadn't gone to her head. she is pretty and doesn't need to try so hard.
6a little too much for me. she looks pretty enough but i agree w/juju... she's trying too hard! some girls can pull it off, others... can't
7There needs to be an option for: "I don't like her OR her style".
8I like her old look better, but I still think she looks great. She's gorgeous either way.
9She is a slut and a is trying WAY too hard in these photos...the sooner she crashes and burns the less I will have to see of her.
I hate this b!tch with a passion...she needs a reality check and needs to not exist
10I didn't watch her on American Idol. But I heard people say she had a bad attitude on the show. Is that true?
11I just do not like this girl at all. I think it is because she looks like Katie Holmes and anything that reminds me of Tiny Tom and his stepford wife I don't like.
12honestly, she is a very beautiful girl, but this is her first phase in showbiz as a star, and if she wants credability she should put less focus on her boobies, she will have PLENTY of time for that later when she needs to reinvent herself, if her talent is for real, of course. Sometimes when you present yourself as a sex object, that is all you are known for.
13What does it matter? This single will probably bomb, no matter how many body parts she shows off.
14i think she looks great! woo hoo McPheever!!!
15First pic,sexayyy
16Second one,slutty
WOW!!!!
17Her mom had her boobies hanging out big time at the Idols finale show. I think she gets it honest.
18I wonder if she slimmed down. I remember her being very curvy on American Idol and she looked great but they always make everyone lose weight on that show. I remember when she was on AI she made attempts at acting sexy and they just came off as being awkward and embarrassing. She was probably just competing with that slutty Kelly Pickler chick.
I think she looks great in those photos.
19she looks good here, but the last 2 times I saw her on the red carpet, she was way too much. She had a very very tight short dress with an open back, which is just screaming slut! It looked good at least.
20Love it! She looks fantastic! Hey, compared to some of the super slutty it-girls out there, she looks like a nun.
21she was super bratty on AI & couldn't stand her from the get go - naturally, my opinion of her hasn't changed - i can't stand her attitude & i definately agree that she tries WAY too hard...
22Right again JK BOOGIE!!! She reminds me to much of Katie Holms to even like her.. I can't wait for her 15 minutes to pass.. she has not staying power... being a slut she is a dime a dozen.. she might do better trying to hook up with Nicole and Paris for that reality fame???
23I much prefer the slut look over the Amish one (and many looks in between the two).
She looks great; haven't heard or sing/speak though.
24She's hot...way to go, girl!
25her song Dangerous is really good..and catchy!
26she looks good
27Pretty Women Boots??? Little too much but she is a beauty IMO.
28*Woman*
29Compared to what everyone is doing lately, these are relatively tame. The boots, however, need to go!
30she looks great but i honestly thought she was rachel bilson at first glance they look so much alike
31She DID have a bad attitude on AI..talked smack about other contestants and then swore she didn't want to win AI and was SO excited she didn't because speilberg was calling.. Whatever hun. Let's see if any of us remember who the hell you are in 2 years.
32______________________________________________________
I believe in the power of BAMZS
daydreamer -- most nuns I know don't wear thigh-high vinyl boots. LOL!
Mar -- I agree that she should have waited until later in her career, when she needs a little boost. I think coming out with the "big guns" right off the bat might alienate a lot of the AI audience that supported her. The usual AI viewers like wholesomeness (example: Carrie Underwood) and usually push people through that are the exact opposite of what current pop music usually offers (people that get through on their looks and not on their talent). Clay Aiken, Ruben Studdard, Kelly Clarkson, Elliot Yamin-- they are all people that have amazing voices but probably won't have gotten record deals because of their looks.
33I think she looked good then and looks good now. I think the first one looks cute. So she's showing a little cleavage -- if you got it, flaunt it. I've seen worse.
34I think she looks GREAT...it's a little provocative, but it's tame compared to a lot of what is out there.
for the people who are saying she had a bad attitude on american idol...i watched american idol and i liked her a lot on the show. she didn't have a bad attitude...she had a personality...there's a difference haha. i've heard from people i know that met her that she's VERY sweet and pretty funny too. i'll be buying her album!
35not a fan*
36She looks sexy. Slutty is sleeping with multiple partners. Ladies, let's not insult each other by calling each other sluts. She is over eighteen and making her own money, she can be sexy. Women should look attractive, not like frumps. We should be happy when other women look attractive. It is inspiring, not threatening.
37I don't know if it's necessarily a question of sluttiness, or if it's one of "look at me I want attention." She looks like she's trying too hard.
38I hate to say it because I totally hate her, but I think she looks hot. Not classy, you understand. But hot.
39She looks neither sexy nor slutty. She looks like she's trying to be sexy, but instead it ends up looking like a little girl trying to play dress up. I mean, I am sure she was dressed and posed by her handlers, but still... I mean, legs wide open, pleater hooker boots, and the come-hither open mouth. It's all too much. It's almost a farce.
I think she should try being herself instead of what she thinks will sell.
40I'm not too sure of who she is but i'm surprised how many think she's slutty.....don't see how.
41It's inevitable that every girl who enters showbiz will eventually have to bare some skin. So I'm not surprised she went in this direction.
42______________________________________________
I must say, adolescence is one hell of a ride!
i think she looks great it suits her, hey if u have got it flaunt it
43I think she looks awesome, she's one of the most beautiful people I've ever seen. Best of luck to her, she will be a success in whatever she does!!!
44SHe looks awesome, but it does seem a little desperate. She could take it down a notch.
45Sexy all the way!
46Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.