I think she's gorgeous, but definitely not in a traditional sense.

45 supplements a day? Somebody needs an intervention. I take four and I think that's too many!

Not even a little bit hot. And I'm thinking she needs to rework her diet if she needs 45 vitamin supplements that are "mostly" good for her.

In my opinion not. She always looks like a man in drag to me, and hat was before I even saw picture for that film she did, umm.. Boys Don't Cry(?).

she doesn't normally look hot, she looks pretty good here though.

Even way back in the Buffy the Vampire Slayer and 90210 days, I thought she looked like a man in drag.

"Get out of my facial."

shes hot!

hmm. I dont know. She looks alot prettier than normal in the first picture. But she has a very "hard" look.

I always thought she was classy and pretty. not drop dead gorgeous but pretty

I have been tainted by comments about her looks. I used to think she was attractive now not so much. I don't think she's ugly, though. I think I like her in shorter hair rather than longer.

I thought this was a man..

100% agree with swwonder above - my thoughts exactly! She looks like a guy and the cover makes me wonder where the adams apple is.

I read somewhere that she got an overload of mercury from all the fish she ate while training for her role in Million Dollar Baby. Maybe the supplements are to help with that.

She's got great arms... that's something, right?

ok, she has a fantastic body...but her face has always screamed: HOMELY and HOMELESS!!! How she snagged and then had the nerve to rag on Chad Lowe...I will NEVER know.

Ugh still can't stand her from the 90210 days, never saw Boys Don't Cry and couldn't care less about her addict husband.

I like the first picture. I do not find her pretty, but she has a nice body IMO.

you know she's ok, she's just not the seductive kind. she;s pretty in a different way. but not a stunner or a total head turner.

RobinFabulous,

you're late to the game, LOL. Chad Lowe is her ex-"addict-Husband", and the only reason anybody ever knew he was an addict is because she totally rolled him under the bus after their divorce.

And someone who takes 45 "vitamin" supplements a day really shouldn't be raggin' on him for a pill addiction.

horse face backstabbing b*tch

The cover picture is pretty, but the second is silly.

She's hot!

Smokin Hot!

"horse face backstabbing b*tch"

I should've just waited for this post and then quoted it with "That sums it up accurately for me as well."

I think she looks hot here. Her look translates well for a high fashion mag shoot. However, in the real world I think she's horsey as hell.

LOL Zahara
And yeah I forgot to throw that ex in there.... I wonder what she had to pay to get rid of him

Don't forget home wrecker. Her manager left his wife and toddler for her.

Should that come before or after the "horse face" part?

"horse face" is the whip cream on top...so it HAS to come last!!!

After. Horse-faced-backstabbing-home-wrecking b*tch. With a vitamin addiction.

Eww I just noticed the inside pic. Ugh ugh ugh.... I did not need to see that. I wonder what the 45 pills are for

There is hotter then her. shes pretty an all but Sometimes she does come off as a tran

Not a fan - cant look at her and not see boys dont cry.

I'm guessing to either reign in the neighs or to keep her testosterone levels to a relatively genderless low!!!

Ohh I forgot to say that a bunch of the little girls at my daughter's school did the locks of love thing last spring, right before she did it, so I think she copied a bunch of 10 year olds. And none of them came out looking like trannies

oh, I was answering RobinFabulous' reasons for the 45 "supplemental" pills.

HOT...i think NOT! this woman doesn't have the slightest appeal to me, and i do agree what everyone says, she's a dude for sure. and look at this, after she won her so called precious Oscar, she divorces her husband, i don't know what happened behind the closed doors, but i am sure they could've work it out!

xo

And her career wasn't exactly hot before she met Chad Lowe. Her biggest movie up until then was that Karate Kid one she did. All of her success came after they married.

The one she claims she just took says it's an "anti-aging" formula.

And didn't Diane Lane do the Locks of Love thing way before Hilary?

I think she is beautiful, and many people have said she is a very kind person.

It makes me so sad to hear women tear each other a part like this. I know it is all meant in good fun, but really...People can control their actions, not what they look like.

I just think, in general, women are getting more and more vicious and shallow and it is really hurting us all. I think when women tear other women down for what they look like, a little piece of that negitivity stays inside them and makes them paranoid about what THEY themselves look like. And then we bash people who get plastic sugery, bash people if they stay natural. Just an ugly, ugly cycle of hate.

"i don't know what happened behind the closed doors, but i am sure they could've work it out!"

I think that is a decision that can only come from one of the 2 people in the relationship. Somethings, like drug addiction, can't be overlooked or worked out.

She appeals to my L-side. Very attractive.

Hilary has always had one of the sexiest bodies in Hollywood. Hot, Hot, Hot!!!

I think she's much more lady like with her long hair - but since she gave it to charity I'll give her the benefit of the doubt here! And that towards all those supplements - wonder what they are all used for?

She's too manly for me...

definitely not hot, however there is something nice about her looks i just can out my finger on it.

I just started liking her after watching Freedom Writers which she was great in and I cannot wait until PS I Love You comes out!!!

I think she's HOT on this cover. Everyday life can be a bit of a blah but when it comes to magazine covers and events she always works it. In a world of coiffed blonde's with perky bosoms I find it refreshing to see a Sexy, Androgynous, Brunette.

Sometimes it gets a little "Lord of the Flies" in here...instead of kill the fat kid, it is kill the ugly chick.

Jillness- you are very right. props.

however..... i WILL say that i don't personally find her attractive and her acting is good but not amazing....

She ruined The Black Dahlia for me because she is the last person i could ever find convincing in the role of a sexpot.