Michael Lohan really got into that holiday spirit at the 2nd Annual Times Square Nativity Scene in NYC yesterday. As one of the most annoying people of 2007, Michael isn't exactly our top choice to portray an important religious figure. So tell us, what does this picture say to you? Whip out your very best Christmas carol puns and submit your best caption for this photo. The funniest commenter will get a great piece of Sugar Swag. As always, we'll narrow down the best suggestions and a winner will be chosen by poll. Good luck!

















Littlewoods
Stiefel
Dolce & Gabbana
Mary do you think we could get him a agent tomorrow or will they be closed on the 26th?
1Wow. How crass.
2okay that's it, jaimie-lynn pregnancy and michael lohan as joseph, the apocalyse is here. if you need me i'm going to be locked down in my basement with two barrels filled with m&m's and cashew nuts.
oh and that's not my caption, it's just my reaction to the photos and with all the crazy news today on popsugar.
3How much do you think we'll get for the gold, forget the frankincense and myrrh.
4as for the caption how's this
lol. kidding.
5ahhhh rosadilia, for the win!
6I just have to comment that I was going to leave a caption comment, but I read the one by karisaamy and just can't top it. rofl, Perfect.
7No caption but can I just say "you've got to be kidding me?????" I'm with pinkflats, the apocalypse is here. This borderlines on being sacrilegious - while they were at it they should have had Britney play Mary.
is right!
8or how about jamie-lynn as mary, le e? LOL.
9Le E
10Michael Lohan fantasizes that the biggest grossing child star of all eternity was his.
11Does this mean that Lindsay is really the baby Jesus? Awesome.
12"How much did your agent say you were getting for this? Do you think he's getting more?"
13"If only the sheep behind me were real... she's got to be better than my old inmates."
14"Wait, only the Three Kings are coming? I thought I told you to call the paparazzi!"
15Holy crap.
16hmm...i wonder if this is bizarre/ironic enough to make it in us or star?
17"What do they mean no rooms, my daughter will pay, she's rolling in dough."
I'm with you Pink, what a crazy week!
18omg this has got to be one of the MOST hilarious things ive ever seen, doesnt even need a caption...
19" I'm not getting paid enough for this"
20How dumb is Michael Lohan?? He's just as bad as Dina!!
There are no words... one of the other sites posted that a photog said "I hope that baby doesn't turn out like Lindsay"
21"Is that Sheep taking my picture?"
"Let's get this kid an agent, I know a star when I see one."
"Bris? There's no time. OK! will be here in 30 minutes for a photo shoot."
22"Oh, and I suppose the sheep did that one, too huh, Mr. Lohan?"
23"Ah damn! I'm going to jail again for sure!"
24he's makes me wanna gag
25Any kid who can turn water into wine is a son of mine.
26HE IS UNBELIEVABLE...he is trying TOO HARD to be accepted by the public...sorry buddy it's not working!
27DUMBBUTT.
"Note to self: abstain from Absinthe during the holiday season..."
28I KNEW it would have been more believable if I were the donkey...
29You know Mary, this is not my first bald child.
30Hey, I have to publicly redeem myself somehow, right?
31good thing jesus wasn't joseph's son...the world would be screwed if the son of god was that skeeze's son
32since dinas living her life through lindsay,this kids mine..and he better be famous.
33wow, I can't believe you've gone so low as to give away a gift for a joke about the nativity scene
34in a desperate attempt to distance himself from "white oprah," michael lohan tries to play the immaculate conception card...
35wow, I can't believe you've gone so low as to give away a gift for a joke about the nativity scene
You DO realize that the joke is not about the nativity scene, but rather Michael Lohan's ironic participation in said nativity scene?
36It could be worse, he originally tried out for the baby jesus.
37"Alright! Another kid I can corrupt and embarass with my disgusting antics" -Michael Lohan
38Yeah, I DO realize it.
39It's still LOW
Besides it's a free country....We can ALL type what we want,just like you did
"Ah Lindsay was so cute at this age... where did I go wrong?"
40padraigin , Don't get you panties in a twist, your anger is showing, be nice.
41"Believe me Dina, I can already see it! This little red haired baby is going to $ave us!"
42:hysterical:
43"No, see - first, you call Disney, then the paparazzi, THEN OK! Magazine for the triumphant rehab reunion! Don't forget the roses!"
44Come on,Mary,let me manage Jesus.Just think of all the money he could make in commercials and print ads alone.I mean,he is the freakin' baby Jesus after all.He,ll be even more famous than Lindsay when I'm done.
45padraigin , Don't get you panties in a twist, your anger is showing, be nice.
46I'm not angry in the least. Why would you attack me like that?
I don't know if this picture needs a caption. Just the picture makes me laugh hysterically. Nativity Scene + Lohans? What is the world coming to?
47Wow, this is so wrong!
Ahhhh I can't stop reading popsugar! Thank goodness work at the office is slowing down for the holidays.
48"So...are you ready for a drink now?"
49"Ali, i know you are hot in that sheep costume, but poppa needs a new car"
50Post New Comment
Please share your opinion with our community, but make sure it is on topic and follows our Community Rules. We moderate comments and prohibit personal attacks, threats, spam, lewd images, or the promotion of your personal website.