whose the dude?

how do yawl find out this kind of information? did maria go to the press???

No Luna13...this has Papa Joe all over it...he went to press to show how "nice" and "generous" his daughter is

I wish he would stop ramming these girls down our throats

if anyone knows who the guy is..let me know! I thought she was still on and off with Pete Wentz.

Isn't this a guy from her band?

I think he's her guitarist.

Kaos, I belive it is the guy from her band...

I don't find it sooo generous to give away some clothes to her cleaning ladie..
She could have sold/or given them to the less fortunate...
______________________________________
\Don't chase the beat of your heart/

Woah, I of course ment, sold them at a auction and dedicated the money to the less fortunate..
______________________________________
\Don't chase the beat of your heart/

this must have just hit me wrong this morning, but i'm so sick of celebrities talking about how they have all these clothes they never wear...why don't you do something useful with your money. ugh.

What is it with the Simpson sisters and holding their dogs like that? Get a leash LET THE ANIMAL WALK. Dogs were meant to run and play, not to be held onto for dear life. They sicken me.

MBM
Wouldn't it have been more charitable to give them to say a church, or a battered womens shelter? There are people out there that literally have NOTHING. While it's nice she gave her stuff to her housekeeper, I am not sure if it is classified under charity (even if she sends it back to her country). Ashlee is in a position to do much more. I'm not even famous & do more for those in need.

Melissabritt, I agree with you. Why is it news that she gave her housekeeper clothes? Once again, her dad is working overtime to make sure that you don't forget about his spawn.
This is the kind of stuff, that makes you like them even less.
Totally agree about the shelter idea, and what about those in New Orleans?

I agree with all the others... give the clothes to the church or what have you.. your cleaning lady probably steals from you anyway

is that her dog or jessica's?

whats with ashlee dating her band members? doesn't she know that dating your colleagues isnt good for business?

She sure like tapping her band for dates..that can get messy. And the only thing recognizable about her is the dog. And even that seems pathetic... great if she is borrowing Daisy to help her sister out...really bad if she got a matching dog..they aren't LV bags!!

I don't agree with giving the designer clothing to a shelter or to the homeless. That's all we need is the homeless walking around in pricey clothes. What she should have done is sold the pricey clothing and gotten fair market value and then donated the money to a shelter or the homeless. The money could buy the less fortunate more of reasonably priced clothing and maybe have some $ left over to feed their kids or something. Yeah it would be great to walk aroung homeless wearing Juicy Couture it doesn't make much sense.....

We donate our clothes to the salvation army twice a year but, then again I don't have a housekeeper to give them to.

No matter what they do people are going to say, "Why didn't she do this, She should have done that." I think it's a nice thing, but by all means should have not been news. I give my clothes away all the time, as I'm sure a lot of you do.

Good for her... I am sure Papa Joe fed this little nugget to the press. I'm sure e realizes that being a humanitarian is "in" Gotta get that + press for his little gold mines
Holla Back!

Pappa Joe definitely fed this to us. I don't care about either of these girls. We all donate our clothes. What else would you do with them? Burn them? I know her cleaning lady didn't tell the tabs about this because that's grounds to fire a person. That family lives their lives through the tabloids. Besides, they can't wear anything that's out of style. They'd be made fun of.

I agree 100% Blonde Sugar!! I think what she did was very nice. Reguardless as to who she gave it to, she still gave it to someone who normally could not afford such expensive clothes. And I also agree it shouldn't have been news, Papa Joe has found himself 2 goldmines and does everything he can to promote them. They are his children not his bank!

Oh, man...I thought the days of celebs dragging their dogs around with them were history.

Ashlee's an idiot, the end.

Wow...giving overpriced outfits to a woman who can't even make enough money in her own country that she has to come to America. ...I'm sure they will all just look fabulous while they beg for food. I know I'm being a smartass here, but come on, I'm embarassed for the tone of this article...making her sound like a Saint. Bad idea to draw attention to generousity unless it's truly life-changing.

Right Miss S. This just makes Ashley look more greedy than good. If this crap made it to the tabs then it must be the first and probably only time she has ever done anything benevolent. I really hate anything Pimpson related! There's just no need to ring the bell when you donate! I wish all celebs would just be silent about donating. It really just makes me dislike them more when they talk about it or LEAK it to the tabs. Free publicity? Um, yeah. Most of us are too smart and see through this publicity stunt mess.

...gave her unwanted clothing to the maid. yeesh! and you think they're so oblivious they actually leaked this little trashy-bourgeois bon-mot deliberately? coincidentally, I saw the two little oompah-loompahs on tv this morning in a movie that also starred a very chunky kirstey alley (sp?) and a predictably cheesey Steve-the luckiest man in America - Guttenberg. what's with our taste people? those girls were just plain trollish looking...

...oops. wrong sisters. but, I still stand by all those nasty things I said about the Olsen twins. don't even get me started on Asslee. if I headed Marie Claire, I would have shamed her publicly for the rest of her life for preaching to young girls about accepting who they are, and then going out and getting her honker "repaired." she's disgusting...

This is nice of her, but those jeans aren't doing ANYTHING nice for her bottom half.

Is there anyone besides me who thinks that guy behind her looks like David Beckham?

What are the chances "the help" is a size 0 and can actually wear this stuff?

yeah, i was gonna say she's either put on a few pounds (not a bad thing) or those pockets are not doing her justice.

Why is this news? Don't most people donate their old clothes?

I thought that was a pic. of one of the Olsen twins.

It's nice that she gave it to her housekeeper. If it had been *me* I would have sold them, and given the money to charity.

Without reading the headline I first thought Nicole Richie, but soon realized my mistake when I saw this girl has an ass. Her maid's family will probably sell the stuff to buy what they really need.

I still want to know who the guy is. he's not Braxton from her band..

bad jeans on her body! with all her clothing choices why is she wearing these pants!

Those are bad jeans on any body. She shoulda added it to the Brazil pack.

I hope those were samples. I can't tolerate people who buy clothes and never wear them. WTF was the point?