The Teen Choice Awards recognized the talents of social-media stars for the first time in the show's 15-year history on Sunday. Just before Bethany Mota stole the spotlight and accepted the award for choice web star, the YouTube sensation took a few minutes on the red carpet to tell us how utterly unprepared she was to make a speech that millions of people would hear. Her whirlwind experience wasn't all about taking a surfboard home, though — Bethany showed us the picture-perfect selfie she took with Ansel Elgort and revealed the name of the hot actor she'd kiss on screen, who she hopes "doesn't watch this." Check out the interview above!