Brad and Angelina vs. Jennifer and Gerard's W Covers — Which Do You Prefer?

March 10, 2010

This morning we got our first look at the anticipated W Magazine cover featuring Jennifer Aniston and Gerard Butler. The spread was photographed by Stephen Klein, who is also responsible for Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie's infamous shoot in 2005. Both twosomes look amazing, but in totally different ways. So tell us, between Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie in 2005 and Jennifer Aniston and Gerard Butler in 2010 — which do you prefer?

125 Comments

2 years 16 weeks

Who cares about Jen or Brangelina, look at Gerard he is soooooooooo sexy how did he get mixed up in all of this. If Jen is seeing Gerard I think brad is the last thing she is thinking of. If he was my man no other man on the planet would exist.

3 years 5 weeks

Enough for Angelina (devilina) she is obviously trying hard and just using Brad to fullfil her dreamed show off a happy family. Yes, folks she is psycho!Whats up w/that rumors that she kept playing around behind Brad.She has no satisfaction and wh@r*!Everything she does is just a show off! Not like Jen,she is classy sexy and real to what she feels and does.

delusion_grandeur 3 years 7 weeks

i chose brad and angie coz i like them but the cover of jen and gerard is also nice

dnkosie 3 years 9 weeks

ANGIE &BRAD ALL THE WAY.

dnkosie 3 years 9 weeks

ANGIE &BRAD ALL THE WAY.

irisne14 3 years 9 weeks

love team jen

irisne14 3 years 9 weeks

love team jen

3 years 9 weeks

Angie is a whore, slut and home-wrecker! She slept with her mom bf, and Mick Jagger when he was married, and then gave herself to Brad Pitt who was also a married man at the time, plain straight classless whore!...but she is prettier than Aniston lol Jen reperesent herself way better. The cover shoot with Brad and the kids is trying a bit too hard to be picture perfect. please.....

3 years 9 weeks

Brad and Angie forever.

Dubn8tr 3 years 9 weeks

Why the comparison? Come on, Sugar folks! I regard you all higher than the others.

3 years 9 weeks

Brad i angelina.Jjolie is hot and pretty. Jenn is ugly,41 grandmother

jenis1 3 years 10 weeks

Wow! lots of pathetic brangeloonies are here with shitty comments.look at the results losers. your weirdo couple are desperate not jen! it's very inappropriate to pose like that in front of kids. jen is very classy and there is nothing wrong with the cover.she looks hot at the age of 41.I can't imagine how the saint will look like when she'll be 41. old and veiny

3 years 10 weeks

ITAWY # 91

3 years 10 weeks

Jen ? Sweet? Hilarious. Jen's been with way more men than Angie has. Ask Tate Donovan how he discovered he wasn't engaged anymore.

3 years 10 weeks

Jen and Gerry are a hot couple. they look happy. she is so fantastic. her body is the best. she always will be sweet. and of course she is better than the skeleton of angelina. who is the witch. and brad is fool who is manipulate by angie. angie has too much experience with men. Jen does not compare with the witch. the best wishes for you JEN.

SandyFeet 3 years 10 weeks

I'm not not going to analyze the covers... it's a publication stunt to get the public to buy this magazine that is W does this magazine is very controversial. That being said in my opinion Jennifer does not have to relegate to this kind of genre. I also think that there is a rape factor going on there which in my opinion is certainly not apropos. Yes, she looks wonderful for her age and she works hard at it but is not necessary that every time she is pitching one of her movies she acts like a porn star. It does not speak well of her acting abilities and unfortunately it comes off as been desperate and not classy at all she need to reinvent herself and get rid of the teenage girl mentality. After awhile it does look pathetic. Both covers are totally different no comparison AT ALL.

SandyFeet 3 years 10 weeks

I'm not not going to analyze the covers... it's a publication stunt to get the public to buy this magazine that is W does this magazine is very controversial. That being said in my opinion Jennifer does not have to relegate to this kind of genre. I also think that there is a rape factor going on there which in my opinion is certainly not apropos. Yes, she looks wonderful for her age and she works hard at it but is not necessary that every time she is pitching one of her movies she acts like a porn star. It does not speak well of her acting abilities and unfortunately it comes off as been desperate and not classy at all she need to reinvent herself and get rid of the teenage girl mentality. After awhile it does look pathetic.Both covers are totally different no comparison AT ALL.

Isista 3 years 10 weeks

*eyeroll* Jen is trying WAY too hard. Sorry, Aniston fans. I just am so over her now. She's not a fantastic actress (in my opinion), and wow, she looks great at middle age. So do a lot of non-famous people. While I don't love the Brad and Angie cover, because I feel it could have been re-stylized slightly, they aren't trying too hard. It seems somewhat natural, even though it's obviously not. I personally don't see the chemistry between Jen and Gerard at all, probably because it seems so fake, just to get headlines. Although I almost didn't vote, because PopSugar, this is just pathetic. You and I both know that this poll was just to illicit tons of pageviews, because there is such a divide about the topic.

Isista 3 years 10 weeks

*eyeroll* Jen is trying WAY too hard. Sorry, Aniston fans. I just am so over her now. She's not a fantastic actress (in my opinion), and wow, she looks great at middle age. So do a lot of non-famous people.While I don't love the Brad and Angie cover, because I feel it could have been re-stylized slightly, they aren't trying too hard. It seems somewhat natural, even though it's obviously not. I personally don't see the chemistry between Jen and Gerard at all, probably because it seems so fake, just to get headlines. Although I almost didn't vote, because PopSugar, this is just pathetic. You and I both know that this poll was just to illicit tons of pageviews, because there is such a divide about the topic.

mayrakn 3 years 10 weeks

JENNIFER 100%! .....of cOurse

3 years 10 weeks

I absolutely agree with all those saying it's been 5 years, let the competition go already. Having said that, I'm not sure what look Jen was going for, but she actually looks like she's about to cry, maybe it's all the heavy eye makeup? I've seen her looking gorgeous on covers, this one was a miss.

3 years 10 weeks

Uh # 83 -- the "W" spread BP shot in 2005 was shot the day AFTER Jen filed for divorce, not before. Angelina and Brad weren't together then at all let alone someone being Brad's "mistress." Although I'm not surprised you didn't get the story behind the pics.

3 years 10 weeks

A poll between AJ and Jen on Pop - S ? GMAB!!! LMAO, what story are Jen and Gerard telling? I'm not receiving any artistic vibe from this shoot at all. Dull, dull, dull!

BabyNorbert 3 years 10 weeks

Why this need to keep comparing these people???But then I should blame myself as I DID actually vote (mentally slaps herself)... I voted for Brad and Angelina bacause their picture is cute, but mostly because Jennifer Aniston's facial expression is kinda weird...

BabyNorbert 3 years 10 weeks

Why this need to keep comparing these people??? But then I should blame myself as I DID actually vote (mentally slaps herself)... I voted for Brad and Angelina bacause their picture is cute, but mostly because Jennifer Aniston's facial expression is kinda weird...

Link Love

125 Comments

You Might Also Like