Which Olsen — Mary-Kate or Ashley?

March 23, 2008

I used to pride myself on being able to tell the difference between the Olsen twins, but lately I've found the more I see them, the more I doubt my abilities. Clearly, this is an important distinction to be able to make. An Olsen twin was spotted in LA yesterday and while my initial instinct is MK for sure, it totally could be Ashley. So which little blonde has her hair in her face — is this Mary-Kate or Ashley Olsen?

View 3 Photos ›

Flynet

109 Comments

2 years 9 weeks

Mary-Kate, because she in hunched in large clothes like a drug addict and hunching. Ashley is more poised.

tkb 4 years 32 weeks

mary kate

tkb 4 years 32 weeks

mary kate

0037sammie 5 years 7 weeks

um, anyone notice the jeans?

0037sammie 5 years 7 weeks

um, anyone notice the jeans?

KristinDaBomb 5 years 8 weeks

I can't decide is neither for me.

herbiefrog 5 years 8 weeks

...isn't that what is so great about being a twin ? : )))you can never be absolutely surewhich one is doing itwell done babes ))

herbiefrog 5 years 8 weeks

...isn't that what is so great about being a twin ? : ))) you can never be absolutely sure which one is doing it well done babes ))

Pi_Phi1772 5 years 8 weeks

Weight-wise it looks like Ashley, and she's been seen in those jeans several times.

herbiefrog 5 years 8 weeks

were sll kindof mixed up shhh... see you soon : )

herbiefrog 5 years 8 weeks

were sll kindof mixed upshhh...see you soon : )

herbiefrog 5 years 8 weeks

you guys are funny : ) keep smiling : )) wonder what it must be like to be one half of a twin...

herbiefrog 5 years 8 weeks

you guys are funny : )keep smiling : ))wonder what it must be like to be one half of a twin...

BeautyXRush 5 years 8 weeks

I cant tell them apart, and I could care less. All I know is one dresses like a bum, more than the other.

K is for 5 years 8 weeks

I think proper response is "who cares, they both look like sh*t!"

mystery2me 5 years 8 weeks

Sugar should always include the "I don't care" option in their polls. You'd get a better idea of what people on this site actually are interested in. Just look at the comments... MK and Ashley get lotsa "I don't cares".

shoegal2280 5 years 8 weeks

its ashley...she always wears this fendi bag

blob 5 years 8 weeks

don't know don't care

blob 5 years 8 weeks

don't know don't care

DCStar 5 years 8 weeks

Pretty darn impossible. On one hand, that handbag seems very Ashley, on the other, the messy hair and black nail polish seems very MK. We may never know!