The key to this look is to play up the eyes with a sparkling, highly pigmented shadow in a tone similar to your skin. Makeup artist Autumn Moultrie used MAC Pigment in Chocolate Brown ($19.50), a chocolate copper/bronze frost, on Rutina's lower lids. If that shade doesn't work for you, try Melon, a soft bright golden peach; Tan, a muted pinky-brown bronze; or Copper Sparkle, a frosty copper. For extra emphasis, line just the top lashes with kohl liner and add plenty of mascara.
Next, in lieu of a blush, try a subtle bronze highlighter on the cheeks, like MAC's Bronzing Powder ($22), which comes in five shades. Finish off with a neutral lipstick and a dab of metallic gloss, like Smashbox Lip Enhancing Gloss ($18) in 35mm, a suede brown, or Aura, a shimmery pink.