I swear by my oil cleanser to get rid of every last trace of my very waterproof mascara, but when I forgot to pack it in my luggage, I was forced to find a new option. Enter: Neutrogena Ultra-Soft Eye Makeup Remover Pads ($8). I usually steer clear of "soft" or "gentle" eye makeup removers, because my waterproof makeup is no joke. But these plush, oil-free eye makeup remover pads gently get every last trace of my eye makeup. Consider me impressed.