I've never tried Maybelline Expert Eyes Moisturizing Mascara Remover for Waterproof Eye Makeup ($5), but I had heard good things about it from a few other people. No product works well for everyone, though, as reader polkadots567's experience with this makeup remover shows. She says:
"I hate this product! I'll admit, I'm sort of a stranger to the whole makeup remover world; this is the first one I've tried and I'm sorely disappointed. I like Maybelline's products, but this one did absolutely nothing to remove eyeliner that wasn't even waterproof in the first place! I had to go back to my standby warm water that I had hoped to give up by now."
Had an unpleasant surprise with your last purchase? Tell us all about it on our Product Reviews pages (your review may even be featured here!). While you're there, make sure to read up on the latest reviews from other readers — there's something new every day.