Skip Nav
Oscars
The 15 Best Oscars Hair Moments of All Time
Sephora
13 of Sephora's Bestselling Lipsticks That You Need Now
Beauty News
Here's When You Can Finally Buy the Storybook Cosmetics Witchcraft and Wizardry Palette

Review of Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner

Found! An $8 Eyeliner That's Great For Green Eyes

When it comes to eyeliners that get the coveted go-to status, I look for creamy texture, an easy-to-smudge quality, and most importantly, something that doesn't creep down to my cheekbones by 5 p.m. By George, I think I have found a match in Neutrogena's Nourishing Eyeliner in Spiced Chocolate ($8). A multifaceted dark chocolate shade with the subtlest of bronze-toned sparkles, this rare gem of a product makes green eyes truly pop — something that I haven't found in a liner for ages.

Even better? The formula glides on very smoothly, even on the hard-to-work-with waterlines, so you won't have to pull and tug to get just the right deposit of color. In addition, it smudges very easily thanks to a rubbery blending tool on the tip, which also includes a tiny pencil sharpener on the opposite side.

Something about this particular shade reminds me of a Crayola crayon I adored back in the day, although the name escapes me. (Anyone? Bueller?) And while I haven't tried the other available shades, perhaps you'll find your own eye-popping shade within Neutrogena's palette.

Around The Web
Join The Conversation
knowmercy knowmercy 6 years
I decided to try this today. I have blue eyes with a green ring around the iris. I also have golden brown hair - sometimes looks a little red. I always have a hard time with eyeliners looking too dark. I loved this! I'm a SAHM - I think I may just put on makeup for the heck of it now. :D
countchocula countchocula 6 years
Ooooh! I should try that! I have blue-green eyes and my favorite eyeliner is from Revlon's Luxurious Color line in Antique Gold. Too dark eyeliners look terrible on me but this one is perfect - it goes on perfectly, gives a nice contour, highlights, brings out the color in my eyes and makes me look more alert. And even though it's gold, it's subtle enough for everyday as well as evening wear. I will cry when that line/color gets discontinued.
countchocula countchocula 6 years
Ooooh! I should try that! I have blue-green eyes and my favorite eyeliner is from Revlon's Luxurious Color line in Antique Gold. Too dark eyeliners look terrible on me but this one is perfect - it goes on perfectly, gives a nice contour, highlights, brings out the color in my eyes and makes me look more alert. And even though it's gold, it's subtle enough for everyday as well as evening wear. I will cry when that line/color gets discontinued.
Sky-Princess Sky-Princess 6 years
LOL! For some reason Raw Umber was one of my favorite colors too, that and Burnt Sienna :-) I do not recall either of those colors having any sparkle in them and I adore all things sparkly! I also have green eyes and you can bet I will be running out to find this eyeliner ASAP. Thanks for the tip!
Deliciousinpink Deliciousinpink 6 years
I swear by this product. It is amazing and I use it as a brow liner..
Beauty Beauty 6 years
Yes, I think it might have been Raw Umber!! Thanks, mnqmcb! Did that color have sparkle to it, or is that my imagination?
mnqmcb mnqmcb 6 years
crayola: Raw Umber?
mnqmcb mnqmcb 6 years
crayola: Raw Umber?
SanDiegoLove SanDiegoLove 6 years
This is great news! My favorite eyeliner by far is a retired Revlon shade called Chocolate Bar. It's dark brown with a subtle gold shimmer. I stocked up before they were discontinued and I am down to my last one. I'm interested to see if this Neutrogena shade is a good substitute.
SanDiegoLove SanDiegoLove 6 years
This is great news! My favorite eyeliner by far is a retired Revlon shade called Chocolate Bar. It's dark brown with a subtle gold shimmer. I stocked up before they were discontinued and I am down to my last one. I'm interested to see if this Neutrogena shade is a good substitute.
Celebrities' Favorite Drugstore Beauty Products
Maybelline Fit Me Foundation Review
Review: Maybelline Ultra Brow Brush-On Color
Review of ShaveMate Diva 6-Blade All-in-One Razor
Review of Revlon Just Bitten Lip Stain and Balm
Review of Olay Pro-X Professional Advanced Cleansing System
Burt's Bees Premieres New Natural Solid Perfumes

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Beauty
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds