Skip Nav
Holiday Beauty
50+ Beauty Products Magical Enough For Real-Life Unicorns
Spring Beauty
The 8 Must-Buy Products From Tarte's Spring 2017 Collection
Makeup
The Story Behind This Boyfriend's Beauty Makeover Will Make You Believe in Love Again

Time to Try a Tinted Mascara?

Wearing brightly colored mascara is usually a lot of look, but it doesn't have to be. The newest varieties have just a hint of tint, adding depth and dimension without overpowering your lashes with color. They work by adding colored pigments to a dark base, which can play up your eye color without making you look like an extra in The Warriors.

Interested in adding a little color? To find out which mascara is right for your eyes,

.

If your eyes are brown: Make the color stand out by using a dark blue mascara, such as Elizabeth Arden Ceramide Lash Extending mascara ($20) in Midnight.

If your eyes are green: Look for a mascara with plum undertones to bring out your eye color. Benefit BADgal Plum ($19) is subtle enough that you could wear it to even a conservative office.

If your eyes are hazel: Makeup artist Pat McGrath used Cover Girl ExactEyelights at the Spring 2009 Anna Sui show. Available in four shades, each uses small metallic pigments to reflect light and emphasize the eye color. Black Gold ($8.95) is gorgeous on hazel eyes.

If your eyes are blue: Look for a brown or copper-toned mascara to highlight blue irises. I'm a fan of Exceptionnel de Chanel mascara ($28) in Smoky Brun; the tri-sided wand does a great job of separating lashes and creating volume, and the black-brown color is very sultry.

Around The Web
Join The Conversation
Lexy403 Lexy403 8 years
where can i find the CG eyelight! ive looked for it at walgreens and it wasn't there!
janetwrogers janetwrogers 8 years
Alas, the CG Eyelight in Black Gold isn't working for me. Pretty good mascara, so it wasn't a waste, but my hopes that it would play up the color of my eyes were dashed. To be fair, I have a difficult eye color (or eye colors, I should say), with dark blue on the edges going steely blue and then green and gold around the iris.
Jive-Turkey Jive-Turkey 8 years
I just bought the CoverGirl one for brown eyes. I love it. I am LOVING the brush too. Go for it!!
audreystar audreystar 8 years
i am dying to try the Benefit Plum!
JaimeLeah526 JaimeLeah526 8 years
I have blue-green eyes and I love plum or purple mascara. I should try the copper too.
Beauty Beauty 8 years
Scis-is-sorrrz, come out and play-ayyyyyyyy! ;)
ImmaDiva ImmaDiva 8 years
I've been wanting to try the CG eye lights too... I saw them in ULTA... maybe I'll pick one up tonight... I always concentrate on my eyes as the main focus.. so hopefully they'll help! :)
scissorz scissorz 8 years
i like the plum idea...i used to wear all kinds of crazy mascaras in the mid 90s -- white, BRIGHT blue, and actual purple. i am glad that is not what the trend is this time around! i'm also shocked/impressed that you referenced the warriors there! people have never heard of that movie before, always surprises me -- so awesome
emalove emalove 8 years
I have always worn colored mascara...blue is my color of choice, I've been wearing it for like 8 years. My friends always say it's my "signature look" LOL. I also go for eggplant or plum colored too.
KimBurnett KimBurnett 8 years
I got the CG Eyelights in Black Gold today and it is beautiful, perfect, excellent, truly. It does make your eyes pop, bacon is right. Thanks again Bella for another great tip!
bacon1 bacon1 8 years
I love the eyelights. I got it in Black Gold, and it really makes your eyes pop!! I definitely recommend it!!
brittanyk brittanyk 8 years
Thanks, Bella! :)
brittanyk brittanyk 8 years
Thanks, Bella! :)
Angela123 Angela123 8 years
I'd like to try it, but I'm pretty OBSESSED with black mascara.If they could find one that would add depth and dimension to my eyes WHILE darkening, lengthening, volumizing..I'd be all over it. Oh, dream mascara, where are you...
ginnygordon ginnygordon 8 years
I love colored mascaras! I wore the great lash royal blue one quite a lot this summer, but it didn't seem over the top because I paired it with light eyeshadow and the mascara doesn't do much (or anything) in the way of thickening, so it was fairly subtle. I would love to try others, though (especially since while I loved the color, I wasn't impressed with any of the features of the mascara)!
aimeeb aimeeb 8 years
Hmmm I'll have to shop around for a cheaper copper version. I'd like to only waste a few dollars vs almost $30 in case it doesn't work for me.
aimeeb aimeeb 8 years
Hmmm I'll have to shop around for a cheaper copper version. I'd like to only waste a few dollars vs almost $30 in case it doesn't work for me.
Beauty Beauty 8 years
Brittanyk, I haven't played around with it on my own eyes but I saw it being applied in person at the Anna Sui show (and held the wand, etc). The color is pretty subtle, but it does make the eyes pop quite a bit. Good volume and lengthening, too.
brittanyk brittanyk 8 years
Has anyone used the CG exact eyelights? I keep seeing those on random blogs and think about buying it, but no one has actually said much about the mascara other than it's tinted different colors.
fleurdelispink fleurdelispink 8 years
I'm not sure about using non-black mascara on my lashes; I might just use the midnight blue one on the tips!
Taylor Swift Beauty Looks
Cover Girl Clump Crusher Mascara Review
How to Get Christina Hendricks's SAG Awards Makeup
How to Get Sofia Vergara's SAG Awards Makeup
Pictures of Celebrities at CoverGirl's 50th Anniversary Party
The Ingredients in Mascara Explained
Metallic Blue Eyeliner

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Beauty
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds