Skip Nav
Valentine's Day
60+ Valentine's Day Gifts That Are Guaranteed to Get You Some Extra Lovin'
Rebel Wilson
The Ladies of How to Be Single Are as Thick as Thieves at Their Big London Premiere
Celebrity Couples
Neil Patrick Harris's Family Snaps Just Keep Getting Cuter

Brad and Angelina vs. Jennifer and Gerard's W Covers — Which Do You Prefer?

Brad and Angelina vs. Jennifer and Gerard's W Covers — Which Do You Prefer?

This morning we got our first look at the anticipated W Magazine cover featuring Jennifer Aniston and Gerard Butler. The spread was photographed by Stephen Klein, who is also responsible for Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie's infamous shoot in 2005. Both twosomes look amazing, but in totally different ways. So tell us, between Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie in 2005 and Jennifer Aniston and Gerard Butler in 2010 — which do you prefer?

Around The Web
Rita Ora and Gerard Butler Hooked Up at a West Hollywood Hotel!
Apparently Selena Gomez And Taylor Swift Eat At Chili's All The Time
Celebrity Astrology Signs
Are Gerard Butler and Rita Ora Hooking Up?
Gigi Hadid in W Magazine 2016
Angelina Jolie's Black Dress on the Today Show 2016
Brad Pitt Movies on Netflix

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

Join The Conversation
delusion_grandeur delusion_grandeur 5 years
i chose brad and angie coz i like them but the cover of jen and gerard is also nice
dnkosie dnkosie 5 years
ANGIE &BRAD ALL THE WAY.
dnkosie dnkosie 5 years
ANGIE &BRAD ALL THE WAY.
irisne14 irisne14 5 years
love team jen
irisne14 irisne14 5 years
love team jen
Dubn8tr Dubn8tr 5 years
Why the comparison? Come on, Sugar folks! I regard you all higher than the others.
jenis1 jenis1 5 years
Wow! lots of pathetic brangeloonies are here with shitty comments.look at the results losers. your weirdo couple are desperate not jen! it's very inappropriate to pose like that in front of kids. jen is very classy and there is nothing wrong with the cover.she looks hot at the age of 41.I can't imagine how the saint will look like when she'll be 41. old and veiny
SandyFeet SandyFeet 5 years
I'm not not going to analyze the covers... it's a publication stunt to get the public to buy this magazine that is W does this magazine is very controversial. That being said in my opinion Jennifer does not have to relegate to this kind of genre. I also think that there is a rape factor going on there which in my opinion is certainly not apropos. Yes, she looks wonderful for her age and she works hard at it but is not necessary that every time she is pitching one of her movies she acts like a porn star. It does not speak well of her acting abilities and unfortunately it comes off as been desperate and not classy at all she need to reinvent herself and get rid of the teenage girl mentality. After awhile it does look pathetic. Both covers are totally different no comparison AT ALL.
SandyFeet SandyFeet 5 years
I'm not not going to analyze the covers... it's a publication stunt to get the public to buy this magazine that is W does this magazine is very controversial. That being said in my opinion Jennifer does not have to relegate to this kind of genre. I also think that there is a rape factor going on there which in my opinion is certainly not apropos. Yes, she looks wonderful for her age and she works hard at it but is not necessary that every time she is pitching one of her movies she acts like a porn star. It does not speak well of her acting abilities and unfortunately it comes off as been desperate and not classy at all she need to reinvent herself and get rid of the teenage girl mentality. After awhile it does look pathetic.Both covers are totally different no comparison AT ALL.
Isista Isista 5 years
*eyeroll* Jen is trying WAY too hard. Sorry, Aniston fans. I just am so over her now. She's not a fantastic actress (in my opinion), and wow, she looks great at middle age. So do a lot of non-famous people. While I don't love the Brad and Angie cover, because I feel it could have been re-stylized slightly, they aren't trying too hard. It seems somewhat natural, even though it's obviously not. I personally don't see the chemistry between Jen and Gerard at all, probably because it seems so fake, just to get headlines. Although I almost didn't vote, because PopSugar, this is just pathetic. You and I both know that this poll was just to illicit tons of pageviews, because there is such a divide about the topic.
Isista Isista 5 years
*eyeroll* Jen is trying WAY too hard. Sorry, Aniston fans. I just am so over her now. She's not a fantastic actress (in my opinion), and wow, she looks great at middle age. So do a lot of non-famous people.While I don't love the Brad and Angie cover, because I feel it could have been re-stylized slightly, they aren't trying too hard. It seems somewhat natural, even though it's obviously not. I personally don't see the chemistry between Jen and Gerard at all, probably because it seems so fake, just to get headlines. Although I almost didn't vote, because PopSugar, this is just pathetic. You and I both know that this poll was just to illicit tons of pageviews, because there is such a divide about the topic.
mayrakn mayrakn 5 years
JENNIFER 100%! .....of cOurse
BabyNorbert BabyNorbert 5 years
Why this need to keep comparing these people???But then I should blame myself as I DID actually vote (mentally slaps herself)... I voted for Brad and Angelina bacause their picture is cute, but mostly because Jennifer Aniston's facial expression is kinda weird...
BabyNorbert BabyNorbert 5 years
Why this need to keep comparing these people??? But then I should blame myself as I DID actually vote (mentally slaps herself)... I voted for Brad and Angelina bacause their picture is cute, but mostly because Jennifer Aniston's facial expression is kinda weird...
Latest Celebrity
X