Before revealing the winner we just had to show you more pictures of Matthew acting like an absolute nut on the set of Surfer Dude, and now he's getting his crazy all over his poor costar Alexie Gilmore. We hope she's getting paid well for the film! She deserves it!
As for Caption It, Sugar, to see who you picked as the winner just
"Matthew got confused when he was told that women like men who are well hung..."
Congratulations Jillness, you've won a PopSugar t-shirt! To the rest of you, thanks for playing and better luck next time around!