Gerard Butler took in a NY Rangers vs Philadelphia Flyers NHL game on Thursday night with a female friend. Just over a year ago, I asked you all whether you thought Gerard is sexy or not and while most of you voted yes, there was a fair number who just weren't that into him. Since then, he's made headlines for getting cozy with everyone from Jennifer Aniston to Cameron Diaz to Shanna Moakler, which isn't the most attractive quality. On the other hand, his upcoming movie with Katherine Heigl, The Ugly Truth, looks pretty cute. I'm on the fence on this one, but what do you think — does Gerard Butler still have his sexy appeal?