Jimmy Kimmel showed off a shiner when he grabbed dinner at Spago in Beverly Hills with his fiancée, Molly McNearney, last night. With an injury that dramatic, Jimmy couldn't avoid addressing it during Jimmy Kimmel Live! on Monday night, but of course he added his own hilarious flair to the story. He told the audience that he actually suffered the black eye and a gash on his cheek when he accidentally hit himself with a car door during a lunch date with Molly. Jimmy retold the accident with a live reenactment that he made with the help of Molly and a shirtless, shorts-wearing hunk, who stood in for Jimmy. The host said that he had to get 11 stitches on his cheek and that his black eye has continued to get worse since the weekend. He added, "I learned an important lesson, and that's that car doors open outwards." Keep reading to watch Jimmy's funny explanation.