Skip Nav
Katy Perry
See Katy Perry in Various States of Undress
Prince William
You Need to See These Kids Staring at Prince William Like He's Made Out of the Crown Jewels
Celebrity Pregnancies
Ciara Is Pregnant With Her Second Child

Who Wore it Best?

Paris and Lindsay are rumored to be friends again, and may have called each other to coordinate outfits before stepping onto the red carpet for T-Mobile Sidekick party in Beverly Hills last night. So... who do you think wore their black and white little dress best - Lindsay or Paris?


Around The Web
Join The Conversation
JessicaHolland JessicaHolland 7 years
Lindsay totally rocks in this dress. I think that Paris looks good but normally Lindsay looks dreadful in dresses but she looks really good in this one!!
Erik Erik 10 years
I think this photo "contest" (huh?) has an easy winner in my book. I am not a fan. of either girl, but shapely Lindsay with the smooth black Pantyhose is a great win over 'too' skinny paris looking like....... skinny girl in a bag. I know that sounds a bit harsh- sorry. Look at Paris's legs/knees. I have never seen legs look worse! Look at Lindsay's shapely legs- and eye catching in a smooth way with silky pantyhose. (SHE is the type that is bringing SEXY back, not a little whiny kid with a drum machine) This look of the (almost) 'mod' mini-dress and smooth tights is very in now too: The "E" channel fashion news went over this, almost same dress, but two different actresses/models, and they said, "The hosiery/tights are always in, if you are thinking of should/or/should not- always wear them" (yeah, they agree with me!). As a gentleman I would also like to say that we (Gentlemen, not little mtv boys) adore women in silky Pantyhose. It really shows that you went just that 1 extra step to be so alluring and .... dare I say, "seductive"! ;) Thank you. P.S. (of course there are some that do not like sexy hosiery, -that greasy guy named 'Vito' across the street from me hates them; "Yo baby, 'gazonga's' baby, yeah baby, like my mudda!")- and that is alright by me/us/earth- so please no death threats. (wink)
ShimmerBronze ShimmerBronze 10 years
i tink because lohan's hair was darker it really brought out the outfit. ShimmerBronze--.
siouxsie siouxsie 10 years
its like having to choose between a plane wreck and a train wreck...
mom2 mom2 10 years
ll looks awful
prettyirate1 prettyirate1 10 years
neither is right!!!! paris's shoes are WHACK!!!! blohan looks ok
mom2 mom2 10 years
paris look sgood!
BlondeSugar BlondeSugar 10 years
Wow that's a lot of votes. I just can't vote Lindsay after that pic of her odd-crotch. and I will never vote for anything that says Paris looks good. so I voted neither
LaurenG22 LaurenG22 10 years
Pad, i seriously thought we were striving for harmony here among the fairies, elves, and celebrities...
what1 what1 10 years
Lindsay looks better, nothing can help vile paris image
TNgirl TNgirl 10 years
I hate to say it but it looks better on Paris. It looks better against Paris's bare legs and I like it better with the longer sleeves. Plus Lindsay's arms are too pale so it doesn't contrast well with her skin tone.
PinkDaisy111 PinkDaisy111 10 years
Ok they both look trashy...i dont think either one wore it better becuase its not the same dress!! But in these pics paris looks hotter!!! ♥ Daisy
Toronado Toronado 10 years
Now, I'm not saying this because I dislike both of these tarts, I'm being honest: I really don't find either very attractive. The black tights & too-short style on Lindsay reeks of skank, and the 3/4 sleeves, shapeless style of Paris's dress just don't fly. Plus her knees are knobbier than a bed post.
Padraigin Padraigin 10 years
I'm happy, too. This isn't a place for the fairies and elves to cavort about pleasing all the pretty celebrities and never saying a negative thing about them. We're supposed to be nice to EACH OTHER, not the celebs.
tony20 tony20 10 years
I'm Happy :)
Souly Souly 10 years
im not a major fan of either girls but how 'bout being a little bit more POSITIVE popsugar?? a fourth alternative could be 'they both look good' arghh!can't stand all this negativity-i thought this was supposed to be a 'happy community'?? love, Souly.X
flutterpie flutterpie 10 years
I thought lindsay looked nice but then she had the whole drooping underwear thing
Padraigin Padraigin 10 years
If a sackcloth and ashes were the "thing to do", would you do it? Honestly, just because someone arbitrarily decides what is "in" doesn't mean it should be worn.
jennifer76 jennifer76 10 years
Ok, it killed me to vote for Paris for anything, but this type of dress is really made for beanpoles like her.
Shiloh-Jolie-Pitt Shiloh-Jolie-Pitt 10 years
Neither. Both should just sink into oblivion ___________________________________________________ "When I read about the evils of drinking I gave up reading"
Islandchick Islandchick 10 years
I think that Lindsey wears it least that's ow i would've worn it...with the stockings.
JK-Boogie JK-Boogie 10 years
Paris looks a whole lot better as much as it pains me to give Paris any kind of compliment. Lilo's arms are too pale and the black tights are a no no...I hate tights...god they are ugly....I would rather go bare legged in the cold.
team_aspartame team_aspartame 10 years
NEither.. they both need to get of the black thing.. paris never looks good :sick:
azucar_maddy azucar_maddy 10 years
woah LL looks really.."medicated" in that photo
pink_magnetism pink_magnetism 10 years
Just because someone wears a "trend" item doesn't mean they wore it better. I had to vote for Paris because her skin tone & hair break it up, whereas Lohan doesn't make her dress a feature by having the dark tights and hair, and pale skin.Plus I've seen that nasty crotch shot of Lohan in this dress! LL looks like shes trying to hard to be fashionable. Paris has accessorised to complement the dress.
Lindsay Lohan's Ex Opens Up About Their Turbulent Romance
Lindsay Lohan Shares a Questionable Tribute to the Nice Attack
Lindsay Lohan's Instagram Photo of The Parent Trap House
Lindsay Lohan's Rep Shoots Down Engagement Rumors
Lindsay Lohan Just Took Her Feud With Jennifer Lawrence to a New Level
Frankie Jonas and Madison De La Garza in Paper Magazine 2015
Celebrities In Playboy

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Celebrity & Entertainment
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds