American Horror Story switches up its spooky theme each year, but there are usually a handful of recurring actors. Series staples like Evan Peters, Lily Rabe, and Sarah Paulson have appeared every season, but creator Ryan Murphy has switched things up for the new season, introducing fresh actors for Hotel. Jessica Lange is out (for now), and Lady Gaga is in. The show has been renewed for a sixth season, and we know that Murphy has approached Gaga about starring again, which would earn her a spot on this list. We've gotten caught up theorizing how all the seasons are connected, but before we get too ahead of ourselves, let's revisit all the characters played by our favorite repeat offenders.
The 23 Stars Who Keep Popping Up on American Horror Story