Skip Nav
Fall TV
4 Telling Signs That American Horror Story's Next Season Will Focus on a Cult
Game of Thrones
Game of Thrones Is Officially Ending After Season 8 — But Will There Be a Spinoff?
Daisy Ridley
A New Star Wars Theory About Rey's Parents Has Surfaced, and It's a Doozy

Buzz Battle: What Is the Scariest Movie Ever?

We're almost at the end of our long battle to determine the Scariest Movie of All Time. The two movies left standing are definitely among the classics of the horror genre: The Exorcist and The Shining. We've heard some pretty heavy arguments for each side, (particularly from my girl Fab, a horror aficionado who is on team Shining all the way) — and even the Buzz editors stand as a team divided. In today's Buzz battle, we'll give you our arguments on why each movie deserves the ultimate title.

Editor S will support The Shining while Editor B will make a case for The Exorcist. Don't forget to make your own pick after reading our arguments!

  • Editor S: As someone's who's long been a chicken about watching scary movies, I tend to get freaked out by a horror flick, and then eventually get over it. I have never gotten over The Shining. It's scary because it's more disturbing than anything; it's not a supernatural story like The Exorcist that you can choose not to believe in; cabin fever could realistically happen to someone — someone you know.
  • Editor B rebuttal: I will admit that I do think The Shining is terrifying, but it didn't haunt me the way The Exorcist does. That face? That voice? The imagery of a girl crabwalking backwards down the stairs is imprinted in my brain! You can't unsee that kinda stuff, though I wish I could. And cabin fever may be real, but The Exorcist left me believing that maybe possession is real too.
  • To see the rest of the arguments, just

    .

  • Editor S: The Shining has just about every horrific horror film element you can think of: gore, psychological disintegration, cabin fever, possession; but none of them define the movie. It's such a complex, well done film with great acting and directing. While there are a few shocks, some of the scariest moments of the movie are the quietest, like when you gaze down an empty hall, see Jack at his desk, working, or discover what's been typed on Jack's typewriter over and over again with his wife. Because the terror is so simmering and pervasive in the movie, there's no time you can stop stressing out, no calm scenes in between the madness.
  • Editor B rebuttal: The Exorcist has all the elements that make horror films fun and terrifying at the same time. Monstrous images? Check. Creepy child? Check. Excessive amounts of bodily fluids (hello, green bile)? Check. Not to mention the over-the-top campiness, suspenseful moments, and perhaps the scariest theme music of all time. Oh, and levitation. Talk about being stressed out — just when you think there's a safe moment, a vision of the devil flashes across the scene, trying to brainwash us all.
  • Editor S closing argument: With most scary movies, you can become desensitized to a gory murder scene, tell yourself it's just a movie, but that doesn't work with The Shining. It stays with you more; even as great an actor as Jack Nicholson is, I'll never not see him wielding an axe at his terrified wife. And I'm also irrationally scared of empty hotels.
  • Editor B: The Exorcist is the kind of movie that you can watch at 10:30 in the morning, surrounded by friends and family, and still be scared to your core. (Ever had a daymare? This is the fast track to get you there). Jack Nicholson went on to find fame with other films, but nobody could ever look at Linda Blair again without envisioning her head turning all the way around.

So, which movie has your vote?

Around The Web
Join The Conversation
tlsgirl tlsgirl 6 years
The Shining is SO much creepier. It took me about 10 tries to get the whole way through it. The Exorcist just didn't make me scared. It was more over the top and I even laughed at loud at some bits.
gamestomper-6 gamestomper-6 6 years
people let me tell you, i gamestomper 6,was scared so bad by "the exorcist," i got out of "satanism"
gamestomper-6 gamestomper-6 6 years
people let me tell you, i gamestomper 6,was scared so bad by "the exorcist," i got out of "satanism"
fakeplanettelex fakeplanettelex 6 years
do NOT even compare paranormal activity to the shining or the exorcist. that is a horror travesty. the shining is hands down the scariest movie of all time to me. i can never shake off the imagery alone - especially the bathroom scene. dear god...
fakeplanettelex fakeplanettelex 6 years
do NOT even compare paranormal activity to the shining or the exorcist. that is a horror travesty. the shining is hands down the scariest movie of all time to me. i can never shake off the imagery alone - especially the bathroom scene. dear god...
bchicgrl bchicgrl 6 years
I love them both but the Exorcist is def scarier. I have both movies ready to watch for tonight to get my scare fix before Halloween.
Deidre Deidre 6 years
Yup, gotta go with The Exorcist. Granted, I find them both to be completely terrifying movies so I'm glad the battle came down to these two. I think The Exorcist is scarier because of the sheer fact that it makes no sense. The premise is that Satan possesses this completely innocent little girl -- no rhyme or reason. In The Shining, the Overlook Hotel pushes Jack over the edge -- but based off his history of alcoholism and violence with Danny, there was a basis for the hotel to build on what was already latent in him. After watching these movies, The Exorcist is the one that I dwell on and that's what makes it scariest.
CaterpillarGirl CaterpillarGirl 6 years
I think the exorcist is scarier, it has better music, a better story (if they had stuck to Kings original storyline? the shining would have been the scarier one, but Kubrick went off on his own tangent) Both have elements of horror, and BOTH have elements of Campiness and bad special effects, but Exorcist clearly outwieghs The Shining in the "I am afraid of the dark after watching it" catagory. I wasnt scared that Mr. Torrence was coming to get me, I was scared that reagan was under my bed.
CaterpillarGirl CaterpillarGirl 6 years
I think the exorcist is scarier, it has better music, a better story (if they had stuck to Kings original storyline? the shining would have been the scarier one, but Kubrick went off on his own tangent) Both have elements of horror, and BOTH have elements of Campiness and bad special effects, but Exorcist clearly outwieghs The Shining in the "I am afraid of the dark after watching it" catagory. I wasnt scared that Mr. Torrence was coming to get me, I was scared that reagan was under my bed.
suzpuz suzpuz 6 years
My vote definitely goes for the Exorcist. I haven't even watched it in like 10 years and it still terrifies me. I can at least watch the Shining and enjoy it without getting nearly as scared. Both great movies though!
JCP0240 JCP0240 6 years
As a big horror movie fan, I really like both movies and think they are both terrifying! But I def think the Exorcist is scariest. That movie has forever left me terrified and I think possession is pretty much the scariest thing possible.
Scariest Movies Ever
Branded Halloween Costumes
The Exorcist: Now With Bunnies!
Disney Princess Halloween Costumes
FABTV: Fab's Scariest Movie Scene
DIY Harry Potter Costumes

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Entertainment
X