Skip Nav

CD Review: Rosie Thomas, These Friends of Mine


In the spirit of Lisa Germano or Gemma Hayes, Rosie Thomas writes very pleasant little pop songs that are just as stripped-down as they are sweetened up. Not surprisingly, this CD isn't the slightest bit offensive — it would be ideal for a calm, classy dinner party — but it's not particularly challenging either.

Before I heard this album, I was smitten with "Much Farther To Go," a chilling, raw, and beautiful ballad buttressed by gentle strings and banjo. But the rest of the album, with its cutesy lyrics about kites and paper dolls, is light and airy to a fault. To hear about the highlights and low points, read more

I hate to dis an album with some truly lovely songs, but mostly, the overly simple arrangements on These Friends of Mine suffer from similar faults: drizzly acoustic guitars and lazy rhymes ("And I do not like the clothes I wear / I'd sooner throw them into the air") that fail to captivate. The simplicity also doesn't help Thomas's cover of REM's "The One I Love," which fails to do anything novel to the song aside from slowing down the tempo.

But while the album is weak, there are several songs that do deserve a listen: in particular, the lushly textured title track and "Say Hello," which Thomas co-wrote with her friend and fellow musician Sufjan Stevens. Though simple, "Say Hello" is catchy and captivating, with a great acoustic hook and boy-girl vocals strolling side by side. The song, as well as the entire These Friends of Mine album, is available in the iTunes store.


Latest

Download our new Selfie app!

Go to App Store
+