Charlize Theron and Josh Hartnett joined Jimmy Fallon and announcer Steve Higgins for a game of charades on Tuesday's episode of The Tonight Show. Charlize, who is promoting the Western comedy A Million Ways to Die in the West, tried to throw off her competition by acting confused at first — "I answer? I grab this?" — and Josh, who is currently starring in the Showtime series Penny Dreadful, was just as hot as we expected he would be while also being way too excited to guess teammate Jimmy's clues. Watch Charlize and Josh face off against each other on The Tonight Show below.