Victoria isn't the only memorable lady in Ted's past who's about to come back into his life. Katie Holmes will guest star on How Met Your Mother as the "Slutty Pumpkin" — a girl that Ted once encountered at a Halloween party and waits for, but fails, to see again each year after. We'll finally see her face on this year's Halloween episode when Holmes pops up as the notoriously nicknamed character. Fingers crossed that we get a flashback to the first Halloween they met or that she wears the same costume, because I'm pretty curious to see how one makes a pumpkin costume slutty.
Image Source: WireImage