Skip Nav
Game of Thrones
Who Is the Prince That Was Promised? A Game of Thrones Prophecy, Explained
Jamie Dornan
6 Places You'll Be Able to Watch Jamie Dornan Over the Next Few Years
Grey's Anatomy
31 Times You Felt Like Grey's Anatomy Understood You Better Than Anyone

Lions for Lambs: An Interesting Debate

Robert Redford's Lions for Lambs is not exactly a cinematic tour de force. In fact, it could have easily been a play, or even a staged reading. Set in three places for the entirety of the movie's 88 minutes, it's low on action and high on talk. Thus, while it's not a visually interesting film, as a spirited debate about current politics, Lions for Lambs is very engaging.

One of the locales is in the office of California professor Dr. Malley who has called in one of his brightest students, Todd (Andrew Garfield) to find out why the boy went from enthusiastic debater to a slacker who's stopped participating. In their discussions Dr. Malley tells Todd about former students of his Ernest and Arian, who, inspired by Dr. Malley's class to do something meaningful with their lives, joined the military. He explains that the two were not the brightest kids and that he didn't even agree with their decision. But they risked their lives to do something important while Todd, with all his intelligence and privilege, was cutting class and slacking off. Meanwhile, in Washington, DC, a senator (Tom Cruise) reveals to a journalist (Meryl Streep) his bombshell plan of action that will directly impact Arian and Ernest's lives. Lively arguments about right and wrong ensue. Actually, with the exception of some combat scenes with Arian and Ernest, the majority of the movie is filled with argument.

For the rest of my take on Lions for Lambs,

This is not just a debate over the current administration's dealings in Iraq, Iran and Afghanistan — what went right, what mistakes were made, etc. It's also an examination of the nature of apathy. In particular, I am intrigued by the critical eye Redford casts on young people — college-aged kids and people in their 20s who find themselves caught in an extended adolescence. The bright, youthful, idealistic and energetic members of our society who, instead of trying to do something, choose to be distracted and disaffected.

What's more, Redford never suggests all these youths join the military (in fact, his character discourages this). It isn't so much a call to arms as it is a call to heart. The performances are fine — Streep is especially compelling — but they are secondary to the issues at hand. Redford is wise and stern, and likable on screen. Cruise is smarmy and superior, employing that sneer that always reminds me of his hateful character in Magnolia. And yet, he's not totally without humanity. Whomever you sympathize at the end of this talk-heavy film, and however you feel about Redford's decision to make it, at the very least Lions for Lambs will get you thinking and maybe discussing some important stuff.


Around The Web
Join The Conversation
ricarocks ricarocks 8 years
i saw his last night as well. i fell asleep, let me rephrase that, i put myself to sleep. cliched script and patriotic crap = coma
catita85 catita85 8 years
i saw this movie last night. While it certainly makes you reconsider some things (e.g. why there are such stupid things like wars, apathy, etc) and the performances were good, especially Meryl Streep and Tom Cruise, i think it was quite stereotypical. I mean, the " heroes", ernest and arian who go to fight are african american and mexican. Is it because they belong to racial minorities that they are better? Of course not, but the race issue is a big part of their storyline, and i got the feeling that redford wanted to be politically correct. But, then again, anything that gets you reconsidering incredibly serious issues like the ongoing wars on Irak and Afganistan is good i guess. End rant.
badkitty badkitty 8 years
i love me some peter berg, just wish there more of him to see in this.
Lorelei-Spirit Lorelei-Spirit 8 years
Mognolia was a great film. I love the talkies, so I'll enjoy this flick.
Zahara-Pitt Zahara-Pitt 8 years
another flop like Magnolia
WhatTheFrockBlog WhatTheFrockBlog 8 years
That's so funny that you said that, Buzz, because I heard a clip of this on the radio the other day (Redford's character talking to his student) and the FIRST thing I though was, "This sounds just like a play."
Linda-McP Linda-McP 8 years
Thanks for a very nice review, Buzz. Looking forward to seeing this and to getting involved in the debates that (hopefully) will emerge from it.
Meryl Streep Is a Terrible Singer in 'Florence Foster Jenkins' Trailer
Pete's Dragon Trailer
Tom Cruise Lists the UK Mansion He Bought With Katie Holmes
Truth Movie Trailer
Celebrities Talking About Sex
Robert Redford's Favorite Movie Role Might Surprise You
Meryl Streep as Food Instagram

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Entertainment