Skip Nav
43 New Movies and Shows Coming to Netflix in September
Fall TV
Your Ultimate Guide to Fall's New TV Shows!
Fifty Shades of Grey
8 Major Things You Can Expect to See in Fifty Shades Darker

Movie Review of The Good Guy, Starring Bryan Greenberg, Scott Porter, and Alexis Bledel

The Good Guy: Very Little Payoff

Love triangles are done to death, but The Good Guy puts a spin on the story convention, showing the audience only what the director wants us to see: our narrator knocking on the door of his girlfriend's apartment. She's with someone else (!) and turns him away with the words, "I feel sorry for you." Seems cold — that is, until our perception gets flipped, and the tale unfolds.

Said narrator is Tommy (Scott Porter), a hotshot Wall Street trader who acts as leader to his office associates, foul-mouthed lotharios with nicknames like Shakespeare and Steve-O whose egos are as big as their pockets are deep. Tommy isn't like them. He has a new girlfriend Beth (Alexis Bledel) who he whisks away on surprise dates while the rest of the boys scrounge for late-night hookups. Or so it appears.

To see what I mean,


Things get jumbled once Daniel (Bryan Greenberg) arrives on the scene. Daniel is a glorified office intern, meekly mumbling his way through the day in beaten-up khakis. In him, Tommy takes him under his wing as a project, someone to mentor at work — and with women. But despite Tommy's efforts to spruce him up with new clothes, Daniel still can't break from his awkward social shell. Instead, Daniel leans on Beth, joining her book club where he waxes poetic about Pride and Prejudice and Elizabeth Bennett. And so, Beth finds herself torn between two men — Daniel is too nice to be true, Tommy too perfect. You can probably guess who is putting on a show.

The storyline was inspired by the novel The Good Soldier, and it draws several obvious parallels. It's creative thinking on the part of the screenwriter Julio DePietro, but unfortunately none of the characters are endearing enough to carry the film. Daniel's shyness and Beth's "perfect girl" routine only come across as boring. As for Tommy, it's hard to find a single likable quality in him at all. Even the script's attempt at a twist feels expected.

Wall Street is supposed to be about drama – high risks, big rewards. You would think that something with such a fast-paced setting would be a little more, well, exciting.

If you'd like to review a movie you've seen recently, check out the Movie Reviews Group in community. I may even feature your critique on the site!

Photo courtesy of Roadside Attractions

Around The Web
Join The Conversation
Rory Gilmore Grumpy GIFs
Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants Reunion June 2016
Gilmore Girls Star Alexis Bledel Secretly Gave Birth — Months Ago
Alexis Bledel Gives Birth to First Child May 2016
Alexis Bledel and Vincent Kartheiser's Brooklyn Home
Gilmore Girls Netflix Series Pictures
Gilmore Girls Entertainment Weekly Cover April 2016

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Entertainment