Skip Nav
Fill Out Our Oscar Ballot For a Chance to Win $1,000!
A Series of Unfortunate Events
24 Easter Eggs You May Have Missed in Netflix's A Series of Unfortunate Events
Dancing with the Stars
Dancing With the Stars: Simone Biles and Mr. T Are Starring on Season 24!

Pia Toscano Voted Off American Idol 2011-04-08 07:44:31

Was the Right Contestant Voted Off American Idol?

Well, tonight's American Idol results show was a shocker and a half. When the lights were dimmed, Pia Toscano and Jacob Lusk were in the bottom three for the first time, along with Stefano Langone, who had been there before. I admittedly was expecting Stefano to say goodbye, but my jaw dropped when Ryan sent Pia home. Pia was one of the strongest competitors out there, and I thought there was a good chance she would take home the crown. Even the judges looked horrified and said that America got it wrong, which makes me wonder whether or not they regret using the save on Casey. What's your take — did Pia deserve to get voted off?

Photo courtesy of Fox

Around The Web
Join The Conversation
kimdash kimdash 5 years
Casey was not talented enough to be saved. This just adds to my theory that woman who are beautiful and can really sing are hated on. I.e. Niicole Scherzinger she can't catch a solo break.
Shannon-Vestal Shannon-Vestal 5 years
I still can't believe Pia got voted off. I really thought she was going to win the whole thing!
gd101 gd101 5 years
And I'm glad Casey got the save, he totally deserves it!
gd101 gd101 5 years
Scotty should leave, as well as stefano!
MelissaMartin0429 MelissaMartin0429 5 years
Vocally, Pia is extremely talented... incredible. However, in terms of performance, she's really lacking any stage presence. In addition, most of the other contestants have taken the feedback from the judges and improved. Pia, on the other hand, seemed content to continue with her ballads and stiff stance. She really had no choice with the rock theme this week but to do something with a quicker tempo. In addition, she seems to have a sense of entitlement and believe that her looks and voice would get her through. She did not seem likeable. I believe Paul or Stefano should have gone this week, but... I don't believe Pia was destined to win, anyway. Lauren has a perfect voice, a sweet personaity, and an awesome stage presence. To me, she is the best in the competition.
mindeelee21 mindeelee21 5 years
Casey FREAKING Adams should have gone home two weeks ago. Then we wouldn't be in this mess.
American Idol Top 11 Results Show: Thia Megia and Naima Adedapo Voted Off
Karen Rodriguez Voted Off American Idol
Michael Lynche Voted Off American Idol
Aaron Kelly Voted Off American Idol
Tim Urban Voted off American Idol
Katie Stevens and Andrew Garcia Voted Off American Idol
Michael Lynche Saved From Elimination on American Idol

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Entertainment
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds