Skip Nav
Summer Entertainment
All the Exciting Things We Just Learned About the Next Season of Scream Queens
Netflix Roundup
28 Exciting Movies You Can Catch on Netflix in August
JoJo Fletcher
10 Reasons JoJo Should Choose Robby on The Bachelorette

Recast "Sex and the City" and Win a Prize!

Recast "Sex and the City" and Win a Prize!

Every Wednesday on BuzzSugar, I post a Recast challenge, where I ask you to choose new actors for a classic TV show or movie. The reader who submits the best cast wins a BuzzSugar t-shirt!

Now, before some of you get all up in arms about this recast challenge idea, remember that this one was actually requested by Buzz readers! So, having just heard the news about the "Sex and the City" movie going into production, I'm making it a "SATC" kind of week. I understand that the original actors were perfect, but since you suggested this challenge, go to it! If you could recast the parts of Carrie, Miranda, Samantha and Charlotte, which actresses would you pick? And, based on the comments in today's post, let's also recast Mr. Big, Smith, Harry and Steve.

Leave your entry in the comment section below, and I'll pick one winner to feature Tuesday, July 10, complete with a "new" cast photo. To see a list of characters to recast and a photo of the BuzzSugar t-shirt,

Characters to recast:
Carrie (Sarah Jessica Parker)
Miranda (Cynthia Nixon)
Samantha (Kim Cattrall)
Charlotte (Kristin Davis)
Mr. Big (Chris Noth)
Steve (David Eigenberg)
Harry (Evan Handler)
Smith (Jason Lewis)

The BuzzSugar t-shirt

Source

Around The Web
Join The Conversation
Cris1192 Cris1192 8 years
Wow recast sex and the city that's hard one, but here it goes carrie-Marilyn Monroe samantha- liv tyler miranda- a 36 year old Courtney Cox charlotte- a youngish Sharon Stone Big-Ewn Mc Greggor Harry-Mark Feuerstein
DecemberBaby DecemberBaby 8 years
okay I know that Samantha has blonde hair but I think that Angelina Jolie would do a damn good as her.
jennacyde jennacyde 8 years
Carrie - Kate Hudson Miranda –Lara Flynn Boyle Samantha – Scarlett Johansson Charlotte - Katie Holmes Mr. Big - George Clooney Steve – Owen Wilson Harry – Steve Harris Smith – Ryan Gosling
NYShuls718 NYShuls718 8 years
I think that this is a tough call, but the actors that I'd like to see recast in SATS would be as follows: Carrie: Natalie Portman Samantha: Sarah Michelle Gellar Charlotte: Anne Hathaway Miranda: Sarah Silverman Steve: Steve Carrell Smith: I'm stuck! Big: Justin Timberlake (could be interesting) Harry: Seth Rogen Now I can't actually see them all getting along, but it would be a funny show, wouldn't it? :)
atomicanne atomicanne 8 years
Did anybody see this weeks episode of TBS's My Boys this week where PJ's friend from NYC came to visit and they were terrible cliche's of the SITC characters? It was hillarious.
orisugar orisugar 8 years
Carrie- kate hudson Miranda- Anne Heche with red hair Samantha- Nicolette Sheridan Charlotte- Calista Flockhart with brown hair Mr. Big- Gale Harold Steve- Mark Ruffalo Harry- Ron Livingston with a shaved head Smith- Chad Michael Murray
jadenirvana jadenirvana 8 years
Carrie-Kate Hudson Miranda-Sara Michelle Gellar Samantha-Elizabeth Perkins Charlotte-Rachel Bilson Mr. Big-George Clooney Steve-Jeremy Piven Harry-Vince Vaughn Smith-David Beckham
lindaloo lindaloo 8 years
I like Whiplash & RCC's ideas for this but I would never want to replace all the originals. It's impossible to improve on what we already know & love! :)
haute-kitty haute-kitty 9 years
I made this a younger set of characters... but I like the mix. The actors and actresses here are capable of doing so many characters... I think it would be a fun show to watch. Carrie - Keri Russell Miranda - Selma Blair Samantha - Isla Fisher Charlotte - Natalie Portman Mr. Big - Ryan Gosling Steve - Elijah Wood Harry - Kevin Connolly Smith - Hayden Christensen Stanford - Kevin Zegers Aiden - Heath Ledger
ktacce ktacce 9 years
Carrie: Claire Danes Samantha: Charlize Theron Miranda: Kate Walsh Charlotte: Amanda Peet Big: Jude Law Harry: Vince Vaughn Steve: Matthew Perry Smith: Ashton Kutcher There's my shot! :)
fashionhore fashionhore 9 years
I honestly did not look at anyones list and I have similar people. I thought I was really going out on a limb. Good god, we all think alike.
Neekoh Neekoh 9 years
Carrie - Jennifer Aniston Miranda - Tina Fey Samantha - Cameron Diaz Charlotte - Rachel Bilson Mr. Big - Vince Vaughn Steve - Zach Braff Harry - Jack Black Smith - Wentworth Miller
fashionhore fashionhore 9 years
Carrie (Sarah Jessica Parker)- Scarlett Johansson Miranda (Cynthia Nixon)- Lauren Graham Samantha (Kim Cattrall)- Demi Moore Charlotte (Kristin Davis)- Toni Collette Mr. Big (Chris Noth)- George Clooney Steve (David Eigenberg)- Luke Wilson Harry (Evan Handler)- Seth Rogan Smith (Jason Lewis)- Bradley Cooper *Aiden - Vince Vaughn This was the hardest thing for me to do. but I am happy with my list!
tigerlyllie21 tigerlyllie21 9 years
Carrie: Sienna Miller (she is quite the fashionista!) Miranda: Laura Prepon (with the red hair, think That 70’s Show) Charlotte: Jennifer Morrison (Dr. Cameron, House) Samantha: Nicollette Sheridan (Sam was so the precursor to Edie) Mr. Big: Benjamin Bratt (handsome and mysterious) Steve: Jason Lee (dorky and hilarious, like in A Guy Thing) Harry: Kevin James (think Hitch) Smith: Kip Pardue (Sunshine from Remember the Titans!)
rocksteady830 rocksteady830 9 years
Carrie- Sarah Jessica Parker (No one can replace SJP as Carrie Bradshaw except Candace Bushnell herself. No one else could ever pull her off. Maybe Sienna Miller, but she is a bit young. She has a lot of living to do first. :) ) Miranda- Toni Collette Samantha-Kelly Carlson Charlotte- Katie Holmes* Big- George Clooney (the epitome of Mr. Big, if I do say so myself.) Steve- Jake Gyllenhaal (A bit young, but the sweetness and somewhat awkward charm is so Steve... and did I mentioned the incredible body under those t-shirts?) Smith- Paul Walker Harry- Paul Rudd *Trey - Tom Cruise (You have to agree that Tom frighteningly resembles Trey MacDougal in his relationship with Katie.)
HelloKittyMini HelloKittyMini 9 years
Carrie: Kerri Russell Miranda: Traci Ellen Ross Samantha: Jeri Ryan Charlotte: Katie Holmes Mr. Big: Bruce Campbell Steve: T.R. Night Harry : Seth Rogan Smith : Jessee Metcalf
hollygo4405 hollygo4405 9 years
See I thought Of Wentworth as Smith but isn't the beauty of the whole Smith/Sam relationship the age difference???? They were like Demi & Ashton before there was a Demi & Ashton. Wentworth is like 34 right?
msshellokitty msshellokitty 9 years
Okay.I have to edit mine.I need to recast Harry. Carrie-Sarah Michelle Gellar Samantha-Demi Moore Charlotte-Jennifer Gardner Mirana-Julianne Moore Mr.Big-George Clooney Smith-Wentworth Miller Steve-Casey Affleck Harry-Michael Rosenbaum
msshellokitty msshellokitty 9 years
Okay..I thought I couldn't recast this show.Even though I know mine isn't going to be that good.I'm going to give it a shot. Carrie-Sarah Michelle Gellar Samantha-Demi Moore Charlotte-Jennifer Gardner Miranda-Julianne Moore Mr. Big-George Clooney Smith-Wenworth Miller Steve-Casey Affleck Harry-Rupert Everet
joeyjoey joeyjoey 9 years
Carrie: Kate Hudson Miranda: Cate Blanchet Samantha: Uma Thurman Charlotte: Catherine Zeta Jones Mr. Big: Clive Owen Steve: David Arquette Harry: Bruce Willis Smith: Wentworth Miller
nm1188 nm1188 9 years
Carrie- Elizabeth Banks Miranda- Amy Adams Samantha- Katherine Heigl Charlotte- Kristen Bell Mr. Big- Gerald Butler Steve- Paul Rudd Harry- Sean Astin Smith- Bradley Cooper
dizzlemcd dizzlemcd 9 years
Let me preface this by saying that I think that casting is half of what makes it a great show. Honestly, nobody else could be carrie. But for list purposes, here are a few ideas for a younger cast carrie-rachel mcadams(only she has the range it would take to perfectly ride carrie's up and downs) Charlotte-mandy moore(she could pull of that classic waspy look miranda-bryce dallas howard or allyson hannigan samantha-elisha cuthbert big-john stamos(sexy, mysterious quality) steve-milo ventimiglia smith-chris evans i have no harry, and i can't even begin to think who could play aidan!
raphael845 raphael845 9 years
(carrie)amy poehler (miranda)ellen degenerees (charlotte)sandra bullock (samantha)jenny mccarthy (mr. big) jon lovitz (steve)jamie kennedy (harry)stone cold steve austin (smith)fabio
paperdahl paperdahl 9 years
Carrie- Patricia Arquette Miranda- Jenna Elfman Samantha- Sandra Bullock Charlotte- Courteney Cox Mr. Big- Tommy Lee Jones Steve- Pierce Brosnan Harry- Brendan Fraser Smith- Ewan McGregor
duncangrl duncangrl 9 years
i'm making a change to mine..i was comment 41 Carrie - cameron Diaz Miranda- kate walsh *Samantha- (i'm changing this to) Nicollette Sheridan Charlotte - Katie Holmes Mr. Big - George Clooney Steve- B. J. Novak Harry- Howie Mandel Smith- chad michael murray
FIRST LOOK: Tim Matheson and Cynthia Nixon Play Ronald and Nancy Reagan in Killing Reagan
How to Dress Like Sex and the City Characters
Miranda Hobbes Best Sex and the City Moments
Game of Thrones Cast Talking About Who Will Win the Throne
Sex and the City 3 Movie News
Sex and the City Fashion Facts

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Entertainment
X