Skip Nav
13 Movies to Watch When You Need a Good Cry
Lauren Graham
One of Rory's Love Interests Just Signed on For the Gilmore Girls Revival
American Crime Story The People V OJ Simpson
See the Cast of American Crime Story Next to Their Real-Life Counterparts

The Results Are In: Recast "Full House"

The Results Are In: Recast "Full House"

Every Wednesday on BuzzSugar, I post a Recast challenge, where I ask you to choose new actors for a classic TV show or movie. The reader who submits the best cast wins a BuzzSugar t-shirt!

Wow, I had no idea the recast challenge for "Full House" would be so much fun! The lists that came in this week were really creative and interesting. Among many others, one of my favorite picks was fieryelectra's idea of Seth Rogen as Joey, and I thought schultzie11's pick of John Mayer as Jesse was odd but funny. I also thought txhottie's idea of Neil Flynn (Janitor on "Scrubs") as Danny was unique, while juliesf's pick of another "Scrubs" star, Sarah Chalke, for the part of Rebecca would be a lot of fun.

As for overall lists, however, my favorite this week comes from alynn! To see who alynn picked along with a new cast photo,

alynn's cast:
Danny — Stephen Colbert
Jesse — Paul Rudd
Joey — Rainn Wilson
DJ — Hayden Panettiere
Stephanie — Miley Cyrus
Michelle — Pearl (the now "retired" little girl from Will Ferrell's viral videos "The Landlord" and "Good Cop, Baby Cop")
Rebecca — Charisma Carpenter
Kimmy — Ashley Tisdale

Around The Web
Stephen Colbert Doesn't Miss His Colbert Report Persona - Though He Was Tempted to Dust It Off For This Year's GOP Candidates
Ashley Tisdale Is Launching Her Own Makeup Line
Making a Murderer Filmmakers' Interview With Stephen Colbert
Full House Cast Instagram Pictures
Wet Hot American Summer: First Day of Camp Red Carpet Photos
John Krasinski and Stephen Colbert's Fake Vomit-Off
Full House: Where Are They Now?

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

Join The Conversation
imtheheppest imtheheppest 8 years
I can't see Paul Rudd as Jesse. Uncle Jesse was hot and had great hair...I just can't see Paul Rudd playing him.
wynnkey wynnkey 8 years
Despite the fact that I agree with these results and the previous results as well, I'm weirded out that Hayden P. has made every other recast list. Probably cause I'm biased and I'm not part of the fan club, BUT - props to her, cause she must be doing something right. Hmmm... It's probably just me. :p And despite my dislike for Hayden, I certainly agree that she would be a good choice for DJ.
Cheetah521 Cheetah521 8 years
this is a great cast! pearl as michelle would be adorable!
scandalousxshann scandalousxshann 8 years
:ROTFL: what a great cast!
bnelson bnelson 8 years
Stephen Colbert...that would be the best and Pearl how great I didn't think of her! Wish they would really do this :P!
leeluvfashion leeluvfashion 8 years
Hahaha, Pearl never even came to mind however when I think about, she would perfect!
elaine elaine 8 years
emmaasnancyfan emmaasnancyfan 8 years
i spelled dakota fanning wrong ups
emmaasnancyfan emmaasnancyfan 8 years
i think dakotta faning as stephanie would be awsome
CocoChic CocoChic 8 years
:rotfl: Stephen Colbert at Danny is great!!
CaterpillarGirl CaterpillarGirl 8 years
I for one, would like to see the name of Hayden retired from Recasting, since she is on this one now.
ALSW ALSW 8 years
Great choices!
CatarinaBella521 CatarinaBella521 8 years
love those picks, well done ;)
blogsap blogsap 8 years
omg, what a great job!! wouldn't that show be awesome?
A_Kat A_Kat 8 years
LOL! I agree with Pink_Lipstick! That's SO funny!
brokenbracelet brokenbracelet 8 years
Haha Stephen Colbert as Danny is classic
ethiopian_princess ethiopian_princess 8 years
Danny — Steve Carrell Jesse — Adrian Grenier Joey — Owen Wilson DJ — Raven Symone Stephanie — Brittany's little sister Michelle — Dakota Fanning Rebecca — America Ferrara Kimmy — Ashlee Simpson
Linda-McP Linda-McP 8 years
Great cast and new photo! Congrats, alynn!
shafiii shafiii 8 years
love hayden, miley, and pual, they seem like really good choices but of course the original will always remain in my heart!
juiceejuice juiceejuice 8 years
pearl as michelle, i can see that.
Pink_Lipstick Pink_Lipstick 8 years
I can totally see Ashley Tisdale as Kimmy!
Latest Entertainment