Skip Nav

The Results Are In: Recast "I Love Lucy"

The Results Are In: Recast "I Love Lucy"

Every Wednesday on BuzzSugar, I post a Recast challenge, where I ask you to choose new actors for a classic TV show or movie. The reader who submits the best cast wins a BuzzSugar t-shirt!

I was delighted by way too many of the recast ideas for "I Love Lucy" to name them all here, but I do want to make some shout-outs before running out of room! I was highly impressed with some of the non-Debra Messing ideas for Lucy, such as K2's Kelly Ripa, Livience's Amy Adams and most of all the popular choice of Isla Fisher. I also liked many of the Ethel casting choices, like Marcia Gay Harden selected by prbeachbum, and ddene5713's pick of Kate Winslet. Finally, I think Pinkflats is onto something with casting John Leguizamo as Ricky.
My favorite list overall, however, comes from pepperatstate! In the end, I do think Debra Messing would make a perfect Lucy, and pepperatstate's other choices are great too. So to see who she picked along with a new cast photo,

pepperatstate's cast:
Lucy — Debra Messing
Ethel — Jane Krakowski
Ricky — Antonio Banderas
Fred — Chris Noth

P.S. — Praise is also in order for marebare's very own self-made recast photo! Nice job, marebare!

Latest Entertainment
Watch Our Holiday Gift Guide Show!