Skip Nav
Movie Trailers
Colin Farrell Either Finds a Lover or Turns Into a Lobster in His New Movie
Oscars
Fill Out Our Oscar Ballot For a Chance to Win $1,000!
Kit Harington
An Ode to Your Saddest, Sexiest Valentine's Day Crush: Jon Snow

Which Reality TV Judging Panel Is Your Favorite?

Part of the fun of watching reality TV is watching the judges bicker, tease each other, and occasionally fall all over themselves with praise for a contestant. Some shows pick their judges at the start of the show and never waver; others add guest judges into the mix; still others (say, American Idol) add new full-time judges to shake things up. Tell me: Which reality show has your favorite judging panel overall?

Photos courtesy of Fox, NBC, Bravo, MTV, and ABC

Around The Web

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

Join The Conversation
LOVErickii LOVErickii 6 years
SYTYCD hands down. i love nigel. mary is alright, & i love guest judges especially Lil C :)
kafarine-tin-tin kafarine-tin-tin 6 years
I had to pick Project Runway. I love that they always have a guest judge, and I love all three regular judges too.
pharm_chick pharm_chick 6 years
i picked PR but i love TC too
pharm_chick pharm_chick 6 years
i picked PR but i love TC too
Allyace Allyace 6 years
I went with Project Runway, but I also like the judges on SYTYCD and Top Chef.
leslievanhouten leslievanhouten 6 years
oh man, this was hard. I had to go with Top Chef...as long as Toby Young isn't on panel. I wish Anthony Bourdain or Ted Allen were regular judges. ABDC and SYTYCD's judges come in next.
NiceDriveway NiceDriveway 6 years
Oh god, when it comes to judging, I always mute when Mary Murphy is speaking.
mo_ri_ah mo_ri_ah 6 years
Top Chef!!
mo_ri_ah mo_ri_ah 6 years
Top Chef!!
weffie weffie 6 years
SYTYCD, especially Nigel & Mary... the judges on the Canadian version are great too, we get Jean Marc Généreux full time :) I love him!
Jinx Jinx 6 years
I like the crazy lady in the picture, bottom left, my son and I laugh the whole time we have her on. She's nuts! :rotfl:
Jinx Jinx 6 years
I like the crazy lady in the picture, bottom left, my son and I laugh the whole time we have her on. She's nuts! :rotfl:
lilkimbo lilkimbo 6 years
I think most of them are great for different reasons, but I went with Top Chef.
buckley9383 buckley9383 6 years
I know Mary Murphy annoys a lot of people- but I love her and her screams! Linda McP ---> So true about their critiques!
buckley9383 buckley9383 6 years
I know Mary Murphy annoys a lot of people- but I love her and her screams! Linda McP ---> So true about their critiques!
simplyfab87 simplyfab87 6 years
Project Runway.
simplyfab87 simplyfab87 6 years
Project Runway.
californiagirlx7 californiagirlx7 6 years
Project Runway, even though I detest Nina Garcia. Heidi Klum & Michael Kors are hilarious though.
Linda-McP Linda-McP 6 years
SYTYCD judging panel s the best; they're specific in their criticism and in their praise. Nigel is great.
hyzenthlay20 hyzenthlay20 6 years
It comes down to Top Chef and Project Runway for me. I voted Top Chef, because I don't know exactly what's going to happen with PR on its new network.
CaterpillarGirl CaterpillarGirl 6 years
I love Nigel on SYTYCD.
CaterpillarGirl CaterpillarGirl 6 years
I love Nigel on SYTYCD.
Latest Entertainment
X