Juan Pablo definitely cavorted around the house with his fair share of ladies, but no one got more attention than Clare. She paid him a late-night visit, and the two ended up taking a sexy dip in the ocean. Whether the two actually did the deed isn't confirmed, but at the next rose ceremony, he took her aside and proceeded to say that what had happened was a mistake and a bad example for his daughter. Accordingly, Clare broke down. He took responsibility for his actions later on his blog, but the damage had already been done.