The ladies of Glee stepped out for Fox's All-Star Party last night, and let's just say, it was a showdown of colorful proportions. Rather than have a sing-off (we'll leave that to their onscreen personas), we're holding our own fashion face-off right here. Lea Michele veered away from her usual sexy thigh-high split gowns and sultry makeup. Instead she showed a little leg — and her enviable tan, fresh off her Hawaii vacation with boyfriend Cory Monteith — via a bright yellow taffeta Lisa Ho jacket-skirt set and a white tank top. To finish the ensemble, she accessorized with white PVC-infused Christian Louboutin Paulina pumps. Her costar (and current face-off opponent) Naya Rivera opted for neutral tones, wearing a nude-colored Alice by Temperley jumpsuit, cinched at the waist, with a matching Diane von Furstenberg clutch and slick, silver metallic Jimmy Choo heels. It's a battle of lengths, color contrasts, and in our opinion, seriously covet-worthy shoes. Now it's up to you to decide who takes top honors for last night's look.