POPSUGAR Fashion Poll Pink and Shakira in the Same Dress at the MTV VMAs MTV Video Music Awards: Who Wore It Better? by Fashion 9/13/09 0 Shares Like us on Facebook Red carpet fashion faux pas alert. Pink and Shakira just arrived on the MTV VMA red carpet in the same Balmain dress! Looks like they were able to laugh it off, however. Who wore it better? Vote on all of my MTV VMAs polls here! Image Source: WireImage Read More 2009 MTV VMAs Poll2009 MTV VMAsWho Wore It BetterRed CarpetCelebrityShakiraPink Pink Inside Pink and Carey Hart's Gorgeous Malibu Home Pink's Daughter Makes Her Adorable Red Carpet Debut at the Inside Out Premiere Pink and Carey Hart Bring Adorable PDA to the Red Carpet Wait Until You See What a Judge Had to Say About Taking a Tween Girl to a Pink Concert Shakira Shakira Jumps In on the Donald Trump Backlash — and Doesn't Hold Back Shakira's New Pictures of Her Baby Boy Are Aww-Inducing Selena Gomez Spoofs Taylor Swift and Shakira — and Totally Nails It 36 Ridiculously Sexy Shakira Moments POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests. Get chic with our daily newsletter Beauty Tips Celebrity Style Fashion and Beauty News Street Style Sign up with By signing up, I agree to the Terms and to receive emails from POPSUGAR. What’s Your Reaction? Thanks for your reaction Don’t forget to share this with your friends! 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Reactions 5 years Shakira's curves take the cake 5 years those boots looks amazing with that dress shakira looks so much BETTER! GlowingMoon 5 years Shakira. What a feminine figure. risqueredhead 5 years Shakira, all the way. I love the boots. tellmemorex2 5 years Omg, I would be so embarrassed! But I think they both look great. myystque 5 years It certainly fits Shakira better but I voted for Pink because Shakira looks like a prostitute. French-Kiss 5 years Sorry for pink, but this dress highlits Shakira. mondo 5 years It's all in the accessories and neither did justice to the dress. billyart101 5 years It's a really hot dress. I can see why they both picked it up! That's such a fun thing to have happened! I'm a fan of both girls. doogirl 5 years I love them both! They both put their own spin on the dress! Briandiesel 5 years I was honestly shocked that happened. Lemerne 5 years I don't think it's thanks to the boots that Shakira looks better, i think it's thanks to her hot curves :) kastarte2 5 years Shakira's curves make that dress more va va voom. It isn't really doing anything for Pink. jenni5 5 years I picked neither. I like it better on Shakira but hate the boots and I hate Pink's crazy hair. rgrl 5 years I think the dress looks better on PInk, with her tattoos and funky hair. The shoes not taking away from the super cool dress is a good thing too. 5 years just because Shakira is prettier doesn't mean she wears the dress better... I'm going with Pink because I don't like the short dress with tall boots look.... The pumps look better! bluestar 5 years Pink! bluestar 5 years Pink! zeze 5 years Shakira, Pink is built like a man, even her boob in that see-though leotard look like a man's pec...doesn't go with a dress made for curves. qtpie 5 years Shakira, the dress looks better hugging her curves KibzeeLovee 5 years they both do look great. but i'm lovin shakira shakira's boots sidra5397 5 years Ha! They're also posing in the same location. The people in the crowd can be seen in both images. sidra5397 5 years I love them both! They wore the dress in different styles and both really rocked it. I really don't feel that one wore it better than the other. Glittersniffer 5 years Pink gets my vote, because she WINS. shelbyrist 5 years Oh somebody at Balmain is so getting fired over this little mishap.