Skip Nav
Award Season
The People's Choice Awards Red Carpet Packed Enough Style For the Whole Week
Michelle Obama
Michelle Obama Just Got Officially Sworn In — by J.Crew
Amanda Seyfried
Amanda Seyfried Already Wore Her Wedding Dress on the Red Carpet

Video: Gareth Pugh's Spring 2011 Presentation

Gareth Pugh's Surprise Spring 2011 Video Presentation Left Many Wishing They Could Have Seen the Clothes Better

>> Yesterday, just like he did for Fall 2009, Gareth Pugh surprised press and retailers with a film in place of a runway show. Pugh, who collaborated again with Ruth Hogben on the 11-minute film featuring Kristen McMenamy, said that he was searching for a runway alternative because: “With a show, a lot rides on that very small amount of time and the whole thing comes down to image. If a model trips or has a problem with shoes, that is the thing that endures. It is liberating for a designer not to have to worry about a show. You can get the models to be even more expressive and do it all in a more concise way.”

Suzy Menkes notes that "the feeling persists that backing off from a runway show is a cop-out or a sign of weakness." Pugh says he is aware of "the perception . . . that people aren’t willing to accept something else [besides a runway show],” and distributed a lookbook of the clothes at the end of the presentation as “a way not to scare people off."

The lack in ability to see the clothes at the presentation was a complaint from a number of attendees, however. WWD wrote: "The film wasn’t really a presentation of Pugh’s clothes, but a presentation of his presentation . . . The imagery was heavily manipulated, so judgment on the clothes was withheld until the classic runway shots arrived, showing what looked like a great collection with a lot to offer commercially." The Los Angeles Times's Booth Moore Tweeted: "Why do we watch runway shows live? Because you can't see the clothes on film. Sorry Gareth, that didn't cut it." The International Herald Tribune's Jessica Michault Tweeted: "Is it just me or did that Gareth Pugh video look just like the last one he did a year ago?" And the Wall Street Journal's Christina Binkley Tweeted: Gareth pugh is a film. Beyond art house. Can't see much of the clothes, but it's sterile and dark."

Style.com's Tim Blanks didn't seem to mind the format, however: "What Hogben's film highlighted was the fluidity and movement inherent in Pugh's clothing. A runway could never have done that—nor could the lookbook images that were circulated after the screening."

Join The Conversation
i-D Magazine Role Model Issue Fall 2012 Covers
LOVE #6 Covers: Hailee Steinfeld, Chloe Moretz, Elle Fanning, Lara Stone
Carine Roitfeld-Styled Jean Paul Gaultier Fall 2011 Ad Campaign
Chanel Cruise 2012 Show in France 2011-05-10 07:25:27
Carine Roitfeld Styles Fall 2011 Chanel Ads; Plus, a Few More Campaign Tidbits
Photos of Chanel Spring 2011 Haute Couture Runway Collection
Photos of Louis Vuitton and Jil Sander Spring 2011 Ad Campaigns

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Fashion
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds