Skip Nav
Award Season
The People's Choice Awards Red Carpet Packed Enough Style For the Whole Week
Award Season
Vote on Your Favorite Dresses From the People's Choice Awards
2016 Election
Does Melania Trump Have What It Takes to Master First Lady Style?

Who Wore It Better? Green Rory Beca Silk Tie Dress

Remember when I said wearing the same dress to the same event shouldn't happen? Well, it did again! Singer Katharine McPhee and actress January Jones both wore Rory Beca's green silk tie dress to Tao Nightclub's second anniversary party in Las Vegas. Katharine decided to go bare-legged and flirty with pointy gold pumps, while January chose a more funky look in navy blue tights and matching t-strap sandals. Who do you think wore it better?


Around The Web
Join The Conversation
mikaela-star mikaela-star 7 years
lizlee89 lizlee89 8 years
plus I luv Katherine's shoes...
lizlee89 lizlee89 8 years
Katherine - her body looks great in the dress. January's tights and shoes are awfulllll...
tkoblondee tkoblondee 9 years
I like the gold shoes that Katherine chose. The blue tights with the green dress isn't sooooo bad but when you get to the shoes, it's like wtf??????? And I agree, it's too short.
freegracefrom freegracefrom 9 years
I'm surprised people said Katherine. The dress is very unflattering on her - it makes her look dumpy.
GibsonGIrl GibsonGIrl 9 years
I just don't understand this trend of wearing dresses so short they might as well be shirts, especially bare legged. It's the three T's of Tacky, Trendy, and Trampy.
melda melda 9 years
breakbrooklyn breakbrooklyn 9 years
the dress itself looks better on january b/c it doesn't flatter mcphee's upper body BUT i think january killed it (in a bad way) with the tights so i voted for katherine
InfernalMari InfernalMari 9 years
I prefer January--it looks like a surgeon's bathrobe on Katherine with her bare legs.
leeluvfashion leeluvfashion 9 years
I actually like January's outfit more.
iamangiepooh iamangiepooh 9 years
katherine mcphee!!!
Sonnshine Sonnshine 9 years
OMG, dreadfull both.
Revolve1 Revolve1 9 years
Hi guys, just posted a new Rory Beca Style Guide for winter. Designer Rory Edelman dishes on her favorite pieces, styling tips and inspirations. Hope you like it!
tatytulove tatytulove 9 years
KATHERINE looks better. but it looks they are coming out with those shirt dresses... ahh
tatytulove tatytulove 9 years
KATHERINE looks better. but it looks they are coming out with those shirt dresses...ahh
emlod10 emlod10 9 years
it lays better on looks awakard on top for Katherine
oriav9 oriav9 9 years
I would rather wear it with jeans:) But, I dont really like the dress.
vinnie vinnie 9 years
I'm starting to have a personal backlash against dresses so short they could feasibly be shirts.
glam-sugar glam-sugar 9 years
glam-sugar glam-sugar 9 years
emalove emalove 9 years looks better with bare legs for sure.
SweetFirefly SweetFirefly 9 years
I don't know if she decided or her stylist decided blue tights went with that, but they were wrong! It looks gorgeous with bare legs.
prosecco-in-the-park prosecco-in-the-park 9 years
I like it better on January but those tights need to go.
Lippy Lippy 9 years
neither - gasp! although, with a different pair of shoes, I might like Katherine
anna_muffin anna_muffin 9 years
Ouch, that green and that blue should never be combined in my opinion. Katherine is my winner.
Katharine McPhee Is Dating Her Scorpion Costar
Creative Arts Emmy Awards Dresses
Emily VanCamp Lipstick at Clinique Event
Katharine McPhee Haircut 2013
Katie Holmes at Knicks Basketball Game 2013
Celebrities at New York Fashion Week February 2013
Smash Season-Two Set Design

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Fashion
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds