ABC Family's 25 Days of Christmas Winter Wonderland event brought the bundled beauties back together, coordinating in grays and black, in 2010.
Troian Bellisario: Tucking a black turtleneck sweater into a tweed skater skirt, Troian channeled her Pretty Little Liars character's preppy style.
Lucy Hale: Lucy topped her black skinny jeans with a sheer blouse and tweed riding jacket.
Ashley Benson: Ashley opted for an off-the-shoulder tee and coated denim.
Shay Mitchell: Shay mixed textures in a sweater tunic and liquid leggings.