The girls bundled up for ABC Family's 25 Days of Christmas Winter Wonderland in December 2011.
Ashley Benson: Ashley topped her monochromatic ensemble with a fur-trimmed statement coat.
Lucy Hale: Lucy married navy and black in a leather-trim ASOS skater dress and calf-hair booties.
Troian Bellisario: Troian mixed trends, working a leather-sleeved trench and distressed riding boots.
Shay Mitchell: Shay styled her dark denim with a shimmering knit top and chandelier earrings.